[2.0.73] Recipe is not considered a Recycling Recipe unless hidden in Factoriopedia

[Shemp]

Load the game with this debug mod. I also loaded the Quality mod to have some other recycling recipes around for comparison.

ZZZ-ShempDebug_0.1.0.zip

(6.42 KiB) Downloaded 5 times

I created a recipe which uses a custom crafting category which I've added to the "factoriopedia_recycling_recipe_categories" utility constant, but the bug occurs even if I use the "recycling" category.

This recipe lets you handcraft 1 Iron gear wheel into 1 Iron plate: (it's in "intermediate-product" if you're looking for it)

recipe-tooltip.png (49.7 KiB) Viewed 174 times

Open the Factoriopedia page for "Iron gear wheel" and look at the recipes which use it as an ingredient. "Iron gear wheel disassembly" is not classed under "Recycling recipes".

factoriopedia-used-in.png (124.08 KiB) Viewed 174 times

If you make the recipe "hidden_in_factoriopedia" by uncommenting Line 27 of the debug mod's data.lua, it will now show as a Recycling recipe. (Using just "hidden" works as well.)

factoriopedia-recycle-recipe.png (130.76 KiB) Viewed 174 times

I'll note that "Scrap recycling" in Space Age is non-hidden and shows under "Used in" on Scrap's Factoriopedia page.

I'll also note that in order to show up as a "Recycling recipe", it must contain at least one item ingredient, so I can never have a fluid recycling recipe show up in this way.

I'm not sure if this is all intended behaviour, but it does seem counter-intuitive that the proper way to have a recycling recipe appear in Factoriopedia is to hide it from Factoriopedia. I was hoping to have my recycling recipes be browsable.

[boskid]

Thanks for the report however i am considering current behavior to be correct: to show under "recycling" section, recipe must have a recipe category listed under factoriopedia_recycling_recipe_categories utility constant AND be hidden in factoriopedia. Without first condition, unrelated recipes that are hidden would be showing as recycling making mod compatibility annoying, and without second condition recipes usable directly would be duplicated in the list of recipes, showing both under "used in" list and "recycling recipes" list. Because of that i am considering this to be a Not a bug. If you believe that a non hidden recipe with recycling category should show under "recycling recipe" and be excluded from "used in" list, then thats a topic for "ideas and suggestions".

Only part that i noticed as suspicious is incorrect handling of fluid recycling recipes, which i will have to fix. Once thats done i will move this report to appropriate category.

[Shemp]

Without first condition (using factoriopedia_recycling_recipe_categories), unrelated recipes that are hidden would be showing as recycling making mod compatibility annoying

Yes obviously, I thought this was strongly implied in the post. It should only work for recipes which fall under that utility constant.

If you believe that a non hidden recipe with recycling category should show under "recycling recipe" and be excluded from "used in" list, then thats a topic for "ideas and suggestions".

This is the gist of the post, yes. As I said in the OP, if this is genuinely by design, then it's confusing that the way to make a recipe display properly in Factoriopedia is to hide it from Factoriopedia. Maybe there's a good design reason why a recycling recipe should always be invisible, but I'd like that to be clear in documentation.

My main motivation is that I want the "disassembly" recipes to be searchable in Factoriopedia without having to go through the "Iron gear wheel" page first. It seems strange that the sole determining factor of a recipe's Factoriopedia category is not its "category" property.

[Rseding91]

The reason why they're hidden is to not have near every single recipe showing a recycling one in the main Factoriopedia display.

[Shemp]

The reason why they're hidden is to not have near every single recipe showing a recycling one in the main Factoriopedia display.

Okay, so if a recipe is hidden, it should retain its current behaviour: Show as a Recycling recipe, but not appear in the main list.

What I'm looking for is for "hidden" to not be required to make it display as "Recycling recipe" instead of under "Used in".