[0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Bugs that are actually features.
BukkabangSanchez
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:27 pm
Contact:

[0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by BukkabangSanchez »

I made a blueprint for a train unloading station that I found somewhere (string see below), then I put down a train stop and tried to align the chests in the blueprint with the cargo wagon placeholders from the train stop. I was not able to align the blueprint chests with the placeholders of the cardo wagons, because the blueprint always went two "steps" (smallest grid cell) left or right, instead of one. I tried aligning it by mouse or by keyboard (by walking left or right).

Blueprint string: https://pastebin.com/e8sVzuHk
Screenshot with explanation: https://imgur.com/a/1tPD16k
Attachments
SINGLENEW43.zip
save, in case you need it
(13.18 MiB) Downloaded 110 times
factorio-current.log
log file
(7.12 KiB) Downloaded 107 times
tehfreek
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
Posts: 391
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2016 7:34 am
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by tehfreek »

Blueprints with rails always snap to the rail grid, which is 2×2 units.
Bilka
Factorio Staff
Factorio Staff
Posts: 3619
Joined: Sat Aug 13, 2016 9:20 am
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by Bilka »

Your blueprint contains rails that have to be aligned to a 2x2 grid, so the entire blueprint can only be moved in 2 tile steps.
I'm an admin over at https://wiki.factorio.com. Feel free to contact me if there's anything wrong (or right) with it.
BukkabangSanchez
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:27 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by BukkabangSanchez »

Thanks for the reply. Do trainstations not align with the rail grid as well and shouldnt it then match the unloading spots from the train wagon?
ManaUser
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
Posts: 263
Joined: Sat Aug 12, 2017 9:41 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by ManaUser »

BukkabangSanchez wrote: Sat Mar 16, 2019 4:29 pm Thanks for the reply. Do trainstations not align with the rail grid as well and shouldnt it then match the unloading spots from the train wagon?
They do. Without seeing this in action I can only guess what's going on, but one thing to be aware of is that train cars are 6 tiles long, with one tile between them, for a total length of 7. That means every other (un)loading spot must be offset by one. The easiest way to solve this is just to remove the actual rails from your (un)loader blueprint so you can put it exactly where you need it. Or you could do the opposite and have the entire station, inserters and everything all in one blueprint. That would also ensure it works together correctly.
BukkabangSanchez
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:27 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by BukkabangSanchez »

Hi, thanks for that suggestion, however removing the rails from the blueprint did not work, it still snapped to the train grid. If you really want, you can test it, I attached my save file and the blueprint in question ;p My workaround was then just to copy an existing unloader, I just posted this because I thought it was a bug and it would be nice to have it fixed.
User avatar
5thHorseman
Smart Inserter
Smart Inserter
Posts: 1193
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2016 11:21 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by 5thHorseman »

As you didn't post your blueprint strings I can't tell you for certain, but my gut says you didn't take the train signal out when you tried to remove the rails.

When I did, it worked fine. Here's the blueprint string of the correct blueprint.

Code: Select all

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
BukkabangSanchez
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:27 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by BukkabangSanchez »

Hi, will check out tomorrow, thanks!
BukkabangSanchez
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Mar 16, 2019 3:27 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by BukkabangSanchez »

5thHorseman wrote: Sun Mar 17, 2019 12:40 am but my gut says you didn't take the train signal out when you tried to remove the rails.
Your gut was absolutely correct, took out the rail signal, snaps to 1x1 grid. Thank you :!:
User avatar
5thHorseman
Smart Inserter
Smart Inserter
Posts: 1193
Joined: Fri Jun 10, 2016 11:21 pm
Contact:

Re: [0.17.14] Blueprint not snapping in single grid steps

Post by 5thHorseman »

BukkabangSanchez wrote: Sun Mar 17, 2019 11:46 am
5thHorseman wrote: Sun Mar 17, 2019 12:40 am but my gut says you didn't take the train signal out when you tried to remove the rails.
Your gut was absolutely correct, took out the rail signal, snaps to 1x1 grid. Thank you :!:
It's super easy to troubleshoot a problem of someone else's when you did exactly the same thing the first time you blueprinted a train station :D
Post Reply

Return to “Not a bug”