Yet another green cells build :)

[LazyLoneLion]

I was experimenting with builds of green cells production. Just for the sake of it.
Keep in mind, that I'm kind of new to Factorio.
Everyone knows standard build, AKA "3 to 2", like here:

Standard build

factorio 2016-03-21 01-29-39-9.jpg (130.46 KiB) Viewed 56447 times

What I don't like is long handed inserters. I just don't like it. You need to remember to build it. it's kind of hassle.
So I came to this quite similar build:

Yet another green cell build

factorio 2016-03-21 01-29-39.jpg (193.11 KiB) Viewed 56447 times

It's the same ratio "3:2" and same container-to-container inserters. It's also symmetrical and scalable.
What's different, is:

1) the design is more narrow, 17 tiles instead of 22. But it is quite higher (15 instead of 9). And you can make it even more narrow, for the price of two more underground belts (i.e. 15 tiles wide and 15 tiles high).

2) it takes more underground belts. 8 instead of zero

3) It takes less iron power poles (4 instead of 5).

4) no long handed inserters Not even one.

Really, I suppose the original build is just simpler than mine. But whatever.
Maybe you happen to have only 15 tiles for green cells production?

[MeduSalem]

I also dislike the long handed inserter sometimes... especially in combination with green circuits. They are just too slow to deal with the input/output. Either they are slowing the Iron ore input or the Circuit output.

That's why I favor layouts similar to this one:

OcLNt2b.jpg (246.35 KiB) Viewed 56435 times

That one is a bit overkill, but you get the idea. Using a belt 90° to the others really helps avoiding the use of slow Long-Handed Inserters.

[LazyLoneLion]

Sure, I get it and like it.

You probably mean something like this (for a usual factory, without much overkill):

GreenClassic

Green.JPG (105.48 KiB) Viewed 56381 times

No long handed, belts, still quite wide, but nice and neat. Just a standard build variation with 4 long handed inserters replaced by 2 underground belts and a splitter (this one is not necessary if side-loading only one lane is Ok or if you have symmetric build doubled on the left to fill another lane).

[BlakeMW]

I sometimes use a "linear" design, something like this:



Sometimes the linear design just fits well especially if your iron and copper are already side-by-side, it's also nice when used with beacons because you can place a row of assemblers next to a row of beacons. Although note if you use 4xProd3 modules you only need 1 copper wire assembler to 1 circuit assembler (a 1.4 : 1.5 ratio). Also bot designs are even better when using beacons, but sometimes bots are boring.

However I actually don't mind using long handed inserters. Normally I have a long handed inserter insert into a chest, then a fast inserter take from the chest. The chest acts as a very useful buffer, I like to build up a stockpile of about 4k green circuits, so when it comes time to make my first batch of solar panels, laser turrets or processing units I can just take a few k green circuits from the chest. I find it particulary useful for making my first ~200 processing units for power armor setup.

[brunzenstein]

I sometimes use a "linear" design, something like this:

Very clever indeed!

[LazyLoneLion]

In fact, there is enough place to put a two beacons per this design without even reserving additional space:

GreenCircuit

Green2.JPG (114.41 KiB) Viewed 56291 times

Every beacon will affect all 5 corresponding assembling machines, and one copper machine will be affected even by two beacons
But I'm not using modules at the moment. It just doesn't seem like important to me.

[The Phoenixian]

I also dislike the long handed inserter sometimes... especially in combination with green circuits. They are just too slow to deal with the input/output. Either they are slowing the Iron ore input or the Circuit output.

That's why I favor layouts similar to this one:

OcLNt2b.jpg

That one is a bit overkill, but you get the idea. Using a belt 90° to the others really helps avoiding the use of slow Long-Handed Inserters.

A thought with optimizing for long handed inserters: What about using long inserters to move the circuits over an iron belt that lies between the wire and circuit factory? Like so:


Ignoring how ah... terrible my old design was, I think it's worth noting that while it's certainly true that each factory must output twice as much wire as needs to be pulled from a belt, having stack size bonus 3 or greater means that long handed inserters will move four circuits at once. That's two production runs from the wire factory which brings them up to par with the rate of a single blue inserter pulling from the belt, pulling out two runs of material in twice the time.

With a speed of ~0.4* seconds to move two items and ~0.8* seconds to move 4 items, that's almost exactly equal to the unmodified speed of a tier 3 assembly machine running wires, or circuits.

Of course the middle wire assembler in this setup has historically been problematic due to the possibility of pulling too many wires from one side and leaving the other half barren but even if that's just a problem for fast inserters and not something inherent to the design it should be relatively easy to work around. (Simply via pushing that assembler one space closer and running an underground belt beneath it)

So if that can be solved then, mathematically, speed modules or modded machines will outpace the system, but nothing else will.

*as pulled from the wiki.

But I'm not using modules at the moment. It just doesn't seem like important to me.

And now that you mention that, I notice that the raw cost of a lvl 1 module is roughly equal to an lvl 2 assembler and a lvl 2 module is almost double the resource cost of a lvl 3 assembler. I'm going to have to keep that in mind for future games.

[MeduSalem]

So if that can be solved then, mathematically, speed modules or modded machines will outpace the system, but nothing else will.

That's a reason why using Beacons together with Belt Setups is too problematic. The inserters inputting from/outputting to the belt can't handle the throughput. If I use beacons then it's always with Robots to profit from the Inserter Stack Size Bonus. Then I can boost the Assemblers to oblivion and never have to worry about anything.

If Loaders should become implemented then they could alleviate the problem, but it would strongly depend on how they are implemented. If it requires a lot of Splitter mess then they are utterly useless because they would take up so much room together with the Loaders that there is no space left to use any beacons... and without beacons one doesn't need a Loader.

If they would be implemented in a way that they allow item throughput from the "input belt side" to the "output belt side", something like this:

Loaders Concept 4a.png (49.46 KiB) Viewed 56230 times

Then I imagine it could work.

If throughput from inserting with an Inserter to the belt becomes a bottleneck, you plop the loader ontop of the belt and then the inserter inputs into/outputs from the loader as an intermediate step using the Stack Size Bonus and the Loader then fills the gaps of the belt running underneath.

If done well with the filtered slots and which items are allowed to flow from the input belt side to the output belt side the Loader might actually have quite a lot of applications. Otherwise they won't be really viable for use with Assemblers/Furnaces.

[BlakeMW]

That's a reason why using Beacons together with Belt Setups is too problematic. The inserters inputting from/outputting to the belt can't handle the throughput.

Indeed. With my linear green circuit factory linked to earlier (using 4xprod3 modules) it can only support a single row of beacons (that is along one side), if there are beacons on both sides even 3x fast inserters just can't keep up with the crafting speed. Although with only a single row of beacons, the green circuit factory with 3x fast inserter on iron plates, 2x fast inserter on output (to chests, you can use 4x fast inserter from the chests onto belts) and 2x fast inserter on copper wire (direct insert) does work okay. It doesn't make very good use of the prod3 modules (because ideally you want them enjoying the benefit of 8 speed beacons) but it's still pretty impressive.

[Kingslayer9]

Heard you don't like Long Hand Inserters, while this isn't exactly compact, seeing as it's 25 wide from substation to substation, you could expand it upwards or downwards, depending on where your inputs are, to the point the machines take all the resources off the belt, my current factory has two of them roughly standing 20 Green circuits tall, at that height it pushes out more than enough personally for an early factory.

Thing to note as Green circuits take 3 Copper Cables is that there is a small amount of down time in each circuit machine, I don't really notice it as if you're pushing out more than you need then it backs up anyway and stops them being put onto the belt.

[gaharmun]

If you put productivity 3 modules in both assemblers, the ideal ratio of copper cable to green circuit assembler is close to 1:1.

At full load, this thing achieves about 2/3 ish compression on a blue belt. (full compression, when using the buffer storage)
It is pretty compact as im using a third less assemblers. Sure, the output rate of circuit assmblers is a bit slower per assembler, but you can compensate for this by adding another row and it is still very compact.

plus: The prod modules drastically reduces the stress on your infrastructure as you only need about 51% copper and 71% iron plate as usual per circuit.

[brunzenstein]

Hi guys!
I follow with astonishment your dedicated elaboration on the matter of green cells. One could/can learn a lot of things here.
My wish is that you would now move on to focus on heavy oil processing, cracking, lossless and economic use and transport of the resulting products.
Start a new subject on the matter of oil processing and transport (barrel or line) please -
Thats a problem for many as the fine- tuning of the output of the refinery site is not a so easy matter - at least for newbies like me..

[Hakusho]

Hi guys!
I follow with astonishment your dedicated elaboration on the matter of green cells. One could/can learn a lot of things here.
My wish is that you would now move on to focus on heavy oil processing, cracking, lossless and economic use and transport of the resulting products.
Start a new subject on the matter of oil processing and transport (barrel or line) please -
Thats a problem for many as the fine- tuning of the output of the refinery site is not a so easy matter - at least for newbies like me..

You could also start a new topic yourself and ask for advice/pictures/help (optional with your current build/idea/problems).
I'm pretty sure there are a lot of people who would love to help you improve your factory or teach you new things. And people who want to show their crazy builds are everywhere in this forum

[brunzenstein]

I though about this too - but - as the level in this very thread is very high (at least for me) I abstained from posting my laymen's products not to spoil the quality.

[zytukin]

I don't like those long handed inserters either. Too slow for most things. But they are easy to avoid with liberal use of underground belts.

I also don't like the thought of inserters moving things building to building.
If something somewhere backs up and green circuits aren't as high in demand, then the wire assemblers would also shut down, with a conveyor, the wires could still be moved to other buildings or a passive storage could be implemented in between the wires and circuits.

So, my solution:
It is kinda crazy, but I was squeezing it all into some empty space.
It's not the *entire* setup as wires also come in from a few other areas.

wires.jpg (280.47 KiB) Viewed 54508 times

[vanatteveldt]

I sometimes use a "linear" design, something like this:

Very clever indeed!

I was inspired by this design to try to "linearize" all production, ie have units that are as narrow as possible, and ideally can be "infinitely copied" (chained) to the side, that is, until the input belts are depleted.

This is two units of green circuit production.



Since you need 1.5 copper per circuit, the two lanes of copper won't saturate a blue belt output belt completely (but probably good enough for me). However, you can easily untangle copper and iron if you add another belt above and below, and use an underground on the copper to allow the iron to reach the assmbler without long inserters.

In the same vein, this is my red+green science:



You can't chain the green science as is, but you could merge the iron with the output lane (just as I did with the gears for the red science) and that would make it chainable. As one green science requires 5.5 iron, a single blue lane would supper 20 green science assembly plants (at 1x speed), which is probably enough for most people

Edit: and finally red circuit production:

Inspired by the "space efficient red circuit" thread (viewtopic.php?f=8&t=18770#p122155), with as only "innovation" that I run the cable+output belt backwards so I don't need the return belt. The copper belt can be shared by a second units above the current one as you need copper, plastic, and green in equal proportions. Each circuit assembler needs 2 from each lane per 8 seconds, so I guess a blue lane of each input can support 80 assemblers at single speed, so you can chain 5 units horizontally.

[SJCubed]

This is my green cell build.

[mooklepticon]

This is my green cell build.

Why go from assembler->steel chest->provider chest->bus?

[SJCubed]

This is my green cell build.

Why go from assembler->steel chest->provider chest->bus?

It's mostly for buffer storage. I could technically change the provider chest to just steel chest but it's in my blueprint so oh wells

[grouchysmurf]

A necro, I know, but I wanted to brag about my approach nonetheless, hope you don't mind.

Like other people here I also don't like long inserters. What I also don't like is the asymmetry in the green circuit production -- 3/2 ratio renders unappealing pattern. While YMMV, I personally don't like the spacing it imposes.

Hence following layout:



I assume use of level 2 assemblers with no modules:

• nine fast inserters starve out half-full compressed belt of copper so it needs to be fed in

• you need ~20 green circuit factories to saturize red belt.

blueprint string

Code: Select all

H4sIAAAAAAAA/63d4U7jyBKG4VsZzW+QUnZsB624lhUDObORIKAQpF2NuPeFhF2dJSZ+usu/RjPT5bTtr6u7364q3z1+u3+8vbn/9vv1r/V2v9lv1s/Xv35t
bx7W19//d/O8v9zvbrbPT4+7/eWP9f3++8XT4/Nbq8ft9a8/ry9jefHX9eXwenG32a1vD//cvF64eZczb3Lm7Yn5ssR8kfv1SJmvUtZXKes+ZT2krHOCy+kt
J7dTtRVYJ7WWsT6964JRkvrl1LtOPe6UwlMiS43r1NDK+bOUR8k58pwnzU1hI3NIiXVKZ7nZM1JKi1OplXiFlFqalFCbD60VWORm6uYgsH7c/GF9t3l5uFzf
v/3PbnN7+fR4v/5sf+hw96nDm+3zerdf7z43bscan+9fc6Z/YN5OmX/V1UV5VyPX1UXK/KjaevNV5YM6jrWiB3V0LPVdHXKSPXomlOzRAX9u/LK9W+9+7h7f
/vx64/HfHl7s/3p6M99sn17234t3ITUv5mNkfu0EvzJspwxh39MXCaJ2lB4n19K3MzJOP97O48u+9PWcG7UgxlWBFq+KR9rkoJ7eh1Vb5wb5uTF+7hmNju3p
PVt1P2tH5+i0Ob2/q+7nuRE2LdPiyTA5l9U91EqHN+pDJvec57p33gF97X7GJofxPk+66HGz0clscp/62Zefv72v575R7zre0b60oylvc24QTw+O4gVQyitX
OsYoHsJnZzbbcdcaR8rXjc3vBa8zRjcpXzzV4gE1tjQs3dBXvP3R8TThpkaGVOUitnYNG6tKjz5kVrD/bIVKeUO14sb3ml/c2ugicOJNjgzG2gVvbpc6Tgum
Lf7vZdw8P68fftxvtj8vH25u/9hs15fN6Ka/fb146+Hm/S5vH5+e1rvL25sfb4++6EqLua50lMgsV1p+utJRWY/bN23dbna3L5t92fVi3uut5rrRbra3ONOF
5n1Q877GueQVcyk+5hqEx3lotgd1dIZ4OXRPy2KH1iIwPTSO14LJ5MNnBf5AFDQ+Toza+Kqk8fLYuJxVdWcMhQW2Jb1sansZlYZ9Qe+Gcql0BZdfFrQteKiL
1Pv7PDymdvnlr6BSmG2d2ecBBruVgtFeMCKj5MkW+JDo6x5McpzH58Exuemo6OLVlN30tNAUTyRRtjJ+t4n5lo5X816u/+/l6pfI7VwXWsx0oWHWB7Wc97HP
c4/NPJfp5rnMas5HFDHr1Zbz3GIMM704Ern5o0WpAytc274P7JK1c1u+5jo8Dv2N8LYHZ1nRn8Nr/sJOVrh9QRfbyi4uUl1ceQ8LbubMY5s6QMRfWFYKLPc+
uX91+u8zvRu4c6uqzoWPzStuGZG55Vj6D9UNr3MO4NzrPzMozTcXr0bbEmc+6junY9WW1eeuxxlhOYbBi6NyDhPRua5Mh3p1Ketl5Ys9TlnVPT9MYtU9P2yt
zllPRe5cffUCKwJ3Vqnn0Keew5Cy7lM9H1LWy1TPu5T11PCf/u166ybV8zZlfeq2Sn+73jrlqQ4za731iZ8r/u1q6ylHNRk3V22cckun/rHAOOVWjv6wwGDK
BU5MBaderHYqT3m0lEM78UjLokdw6g6rJ8OUd0s5t5Rvy7i2nHNJ/nC9T0wYZx515oYz4srcb2a5kFFWxqFkxlLGf2cWR5mlcMZ/Zubo3OxzOkdXTj6ZtXhq
aXa6tirYQ2ZWGVeF64TUwju1/pxcdk8E3Z26zNrpObXpSu09Uluu1M4jtcFO7TNT2+vULnMSj0zGoFYbZ3YdKaKQQmEpGnWK0Up/ufqej56l0KAoanbE8b1e
7Df3h/opp1D1PX/4eOnbx+3tbr0/HPyNtOuxXYftltiuxXYNtgtrt7BmeDXsHN4rPjp8E/BiWxRKi0JpUSgtCqVFobQolBaF0ppQWhNKa0JpTSitCaU1obQm
lAaF0qBQGhRKg0JpUCgNCqVBoTQmlMaE0phQGhNKY0JpTCiNCSVQKIFCCRRKoFAChRIolEChhAklTChhQgkTSphQwoQSJpQFCmWBQlmgUBYolAUKZYFCWaBQ
FiaUhQllYUJZmFAWJpSFCWVBQvm3dA+10+tNd+/Ybvpu/00+oXbT7+LfmGNpNy2Uf+J5pRl2Du8VHx2+CXixKxTKCoWyQqGsUCgrFMoKhbJCoaxMKCsTysqE
sjKhrEwoKxPKyoQyoFAGFMqAQhlQKAMKZUChDCiUwYQymFAGE8pgQhlMKIMJZTCh9CiUHoXSo1B6FEqPQulRKD0KpTeh9CaU3oTSm1B6E0pvQulNKB0KpUOh
dCiUDoXSoVA6FEqHQulMKJ0JpTOhdCaUzoTSmVA6EwqS2UAyG0hmA8lsIJkNJLOBZDaMzIaR2TAyG0Zmw8hsGJkNI7OBZDaQzAaS2UAyG0hmA8lsIJkNI7Nh
ZDaMzIaR2TAyG0Zmw8hsIJkNJLOBZDaQzAaS2UAyG0hmw8hsGJkNI7NhZDaMzIaR2TAyG0hmA8lsIJkNJLOBZDaQzAaS2TAyG0Zmw8hsGJkNI7NhZDaMzAaS
2UAyG0hmA8lsIJkNJLOBZDaMzIaR2TAyG0Zmw8hsGJkNI7MIZpHLIpZFKotQFpksIlkjsgZkjccajjUaazDWWCyiWCSxCGKRwyKGRQqLENYYrCFYI7AGYI2/
Gn41+orwFdkrolckrwhekbsidjXqatDVmKshVyOuBlyNtyJuRdqKsBVZK6JWJK0IWo2zGmY1ymqQ1RirIVYjrAhYka8iXkW6inAV2SqiVSOrBlaNqxpWNapq
UNWYKiJVJKoIVJGnIk5Fmoow1ViqoVQjqQZSjaMaRjWKihAVGSoiVCSoCFCRnyI+NXpq8NTYqaFTI6cGTjGi1aSh8awmDY1mNWloLKtJAyNZSRoYx0rSwChW
kgaSUuRfiL+QfiH8QvaF6AvJl4Ev416GvYx6GfQy5iXSMDJqXNSoqDFRI6LGQ42GEgslEkoclCgoMVAioMQ/zU2YlzAnYT7CXIR5CHMQ5B/IPZB3IOdAvoFc
A3kGW07YasIWE7aWsKWErSRsIUHrCFpG0CqCFhG0hqAlBK0gbNthuw7bdNiew7YctuOwDQftN2i7QbsN2mzQXoO2GrTTMDxhdMLghLEJQxNGJgxMEJcgLEFU
gqAEMQlCEkQkDGMaxTSIaQzTEKYRTAOYxC8JXxK9JHhJ7JLQJZFLO+6w0w477LCzDjvqsJMOO+igcw465qBTDjrkoDMOOuKgEw47FrVTUTsUtTNROxK1E1E7
EKXzUDoOpdNQOgyls1A6CqWTUAufsOgJC56w2AkLnbDICQucoLgJCpugqAkKmqCYCQqZoIgJC7OyKCsLsrIYKwuxsggrC7Ci+CoKr6LoKgquotgqCq2iyCoM
zsTYTAzNxMhMDMzEuEwMy7SoTAvKtJhMC8m0iEwLyLR4TAzwxvhuDO/G6G4M7sbYbgzttshuC+y2uG4L67aobgvqtphuTBLBHBFMEcEMEUwQwfwQTA+x7BBL
DrHcEEsNscwQSwyxvBBMNMM8M0wzwywzTDLDHDNMMbMMM0sws/wySy+z7DJLLrPcMkxWxVxVTFXFTFVMVMU8VUxTtSxVS1K1HFVLUbUMVUtQtfxUTHjHfHdM
d8dsd0x2x1x3THW3THdLdLc8d0tztyx3S3K3HHcsmoE1M7BkBlbMwIIZWC8Dy2VYtQwrlmG1MqxUhlXKsEIZVicDC+9g3R0su4NVd7DoDtbcwZI7VnHHCu5Y
vR0rt2PVdqzYjtXaweJdWLsLS3dh5S4s3IV1u7Bsl1XtsqJdVrPLSnZZxS4r2GX1urAAINb/w/J/WP0Pi/9h7T8s/WeV/6zwn9X9s7J/VvXPiv5ZzT8sIoo1
RLGEKFYQxQKiWD8Uy4da9VArHmq1Q610qFUOtcKhVjcUCxFjHWIsQ4xViLEIMdYgxhLEVoHYChBb/WErP2zVh634sNUexmLmWMscS5ljJXMsZI51zLGMuVUx
tyLmVsPcSphbBXMrYG71y/GDCPg9BPwcAn4NAT+GgN9CwE8h2JcQ7EMI9h0E+wyCfQXBPoLw1TcQXi82b395/7rK8+bn9ub++tfHF8H264fvH61vnp/XDz/u
N9uflw83t39stuvL5u36m+3d+s/3J3LGdOyLL/9YNq+vr7+99eJlt/32+2/r7d3fvB67WDerAAA=