[Klonan] Smarter/Better Platform drop logic

[trad_emark]

I have build a second platform above nauvis. My intention was to send down free (infinite) resources from asteroids. However, the platform is refusing to send the resources down.

There is no indication anywhere in the gui why it is not sending the resources.

Resources from the first platform are being dropped down ok.

Tested on both versions 2.0.9 and 2.0.10.

factorio_platform.png (3.84 MiB) Viewed 2083 times

factorio_nauvis.png (7.29 MiB) Viewed 2083 times

[mmmPI]

How long does this stay like this ? because there is a cooldown to how fast platform can drop ressources. You can increase the throughput by adding cargobays next to the landing pad.

[Makka77]

I struggled with this too.

As far as i can tell, instead of setting a request on the ground you set a request of zero on the platform and it trashes it into the drop slots.

[Klonan]

I have build a second platform above nauvis. My intention was to send down free (infinite) resources from asteroids. However, the platform is refusing to send the resources down.

There is no indication anywhere in the gui why it is not sending the resources.

Resources from the first platform are being dropped down ok.

Hi,

Can you provide a save game?

[trad_emark]

I have build a second platform above nauvis. My intention was to send down free (infinite) resources from asteroids. However, the platform is refusing to send the resources down.

There is no indication anywhere in the gui why it is not sending the resources.

Resources from the first platform are being dropped down ok.

Hi,

Can you provide a save game?

Here is the save. Thanks for looking into this.

[trad_emark]

I struggled with this too.

As far as i can tell, instead of setting a request on the ground you set a request of zero on the platform and it trashes it into the drop slots.

This is brilliant idea. I will try this.

However, I am still curious what is the issue with my initial setup. I assume it is intended to work that way, right?

[Klonan]

It seems the first platform is spamming up the landing pad with the small little deliveries of iron

If you build some more cargo bays the landing pad will allow more incoming pods, so the situation resolves itself a bit better

I will keep this card around as we do want to make the dropping logic smarter in the future

[trad_emark]

It seems the first platform is spamming up the landing pad with the small little deliveries of iron

If you build some more cargo bays the landing pad will allow more incoming pods, so the situation resolves itself a bit better

I will keep this card around as we do want to make the dropping logic smarter in the future

Thanks for the explanation. I have added few Cargo bays, and setup the thrashing instead of requests, as suggested by Makka77, and it is working much smoother now. Thanks you everyone for helping

[Zaflis]

I struggled with this too.

As far as i can tell, instead of setting a request on the ground you set a request of zero on the platform and it trashes it into the drop slots.

It's situational. It's fine to send all depleted uranium fuel with platform having 0 / 0 request. But if i were to do that for space science it would completely flood my planet's logistics system. It would have to recycle all excess or just do easier way that is set request with circuit in the landing pad.

[Makka77]

It's situational. It's fine to send all depleted uranium fuel with platform having 0 / 0 request. But if i were to do that for space science it would completely flood my planet's logistics system. It would have to recycle all excess or just do easier way that is set request with circuit in the landing pad.

I understand this is not necessarily the intended way of using them. It felt hacky, but it worked for my little 45spm base. I see how it would not scale and there are things I'm not understanding yet. Damn I'm having fun though!

[orangemammut]

I have a similar problem, I have a station that builds science, and drops the surplus of iron and carbon to the landing pad on the planet. After a while it just stops sending two of the items, and only sends small batches of one.

Also, anything in the drop slots is not sent down.

I tried the suggestion and built two extra cargo bays, but that did not help with sending down the items in drop slots.

I did notice that if I disable the requests for iron,carbon, and science in the cargo landing pad, then quite soon after the items from the drop slots are sent down, so that is currently a work-around for when I incidentally want to drop something else.

If you wish I can attach the save file where the drop-slots are not working.

[Klonan]

I was curious and looked into it a bit more, and there was an oversight in the implementation which prevented the request cycling logic to work correctly

It is not 'fixed' fixed, in that the logic isn't perfect now, but now at least over time all deliveries are being fulfilled here and there.
In the future we will probably improve it more, but this was simple and should help a lot