New stop condition for Trains...

[PanTobi]

TL;DR

New conditions for Trains:
:: If item count less / more for each wagon
:: If low on fuel
:: If other train is waiting

What ?

:: If item count less / more for each wagon
atm. we have condition to check for full/empty or item amount in cargo... but its not enough :/...
Lets say that we have 1-2 and one wagon is empty but second is full... in this situation without balancer half of our smelters do nothing...



:: If low on fuel
In late i just build one / two "refuel" stations where Train stop on every loop to take fuel...
Because in early its fine to feed then on Stop / Start but in late where you have 50+ Train Stops?...

Yeee sure u can move Fuel with Bots... but i dont use bots... ( im using them only for MK2 eq and Power ( Uranium ) )
Actualy... Train should have "special" fuel stop, so we can pick Train Stop where Train can go when on low Fuel :c...



:: If other train is waiting
This might be little hard to do for Dev-s but it would be rly cool to have option to leave Train Stop if another train is already waiting
for example * condition for Train
if( empty_cargo )
or
if( ( Item < 2000 ) && ( TimePass > 30 || OtherTrainWaiting ) )

Why ?

Its very important :c...
Look at this Train ( One_Wagon_Train SS ), one wagon is still pretty full and because of that one wagon my Train
will stop here for long time with 3 empty wagons and one full... ofc. its my bad because i could use Balancer...

but tbh. this design is just cut from my other factory where i produce 200.000 iron / minute
Just look at "Train" Screenshot, here i can't build balancer because its direct in/out from smelter to trains

and tbh. all my stops works to be FAST so not everything is always balanced... ( Loader SS )
with option to check amount of items in EVERY wagon INSTEAD of items in WHOLE TRAIN... this could work even faster ...

Plz new Train conditions for me T_T...

One_Wagon_Train

427520_20201230035231_1.png (1.24 MiB) Viewed 3367 times

Two_Wagon_Train

427520_20201230035238_1.png (1.2 MiB) Viewed 3367 times

JustRandomSSXD

s1.png (19.43 KiB) Viewed 3367 times

Train

s1.png (493.71 KiB) Viewed 3367 times

Loader

s1.png (1.62 MiB) Viewed 3367 times

Yes it took me long to color and format everything <3

[SoShootMe]

:: If item count less / more for each wagon

"Any wagon" and "All wagons" variants of item/fluid count and full/empty might have some uses, but for bulk transport, you want to balance unloading in order to maximise the amount transported per train journey and have no need of such conditions.

You don't necessarily need to balance as you unload a train. For example, when unloading ore into furnaces, you could balance furnace output instead.

:: If low on fuel

The main value I can see of this is with "entry conditions" (which have previously been suggested), so you could say "skip the refuel stop if all locomotive fuel > n%".

For now, distributing fuel is just part of the game. Logistic robots make this easy and flexible, but if you don't want to use them then run belts past the stops (which favours grouping stops together) or have fuel depots at strategic locations.

:: If other train is waiting

I've never felt a need for this so I haven't tried it, but it should be fairly easily possible using the circuit network. A rail signal can send its state to the circuit network: being red indicates there is a train in the block it protects, which can be used to detect a train waiting. This can be used to provide a circuit network signal to the stop, which you can check in a wait condition.

[ssilk]

:: If item count less / more for each wagon
atm. we have condition to check for full/empty or item amount in cargo... but its not enough :/...
Lets say that we have 1-2 and one wagon is empty but second is full... in this situation without balancer half of our smelters do nothing...

Then add a balancer? Or change the waiting condition to 50%.
It’s the players responsibility in my opinion.

:: If low on fuel
In late i just build one / two "refuel" stations where Train stop on every loop to take fuel...
Because in early its fine to feed then on Stop / Start but in late where you have 50+ Train Stops?...

Yeee sure u can move Fuel with Bots... but i dont use bots... ( im using them only for MK2 eq and Power ( Uranium ) )
Actualy... Train should have "special" fuel stop, so we can pick Train Stop where Train can go when on low Fuel :c...

There are several mods, that will enable you to send trains to some kind of refuel station.

Yes it took me long to color and format everything <3

I hope you had fun, because it is not so fun to read that BBCode-chaos in the editor.

See also viewtopic.php?f=6&t=3394

You like colors? We like content! Don't use colors in text if there is no good reason.

[PanTobi]

Why u bully me so much silk T,T u probably hate me T-T

Can you give me 4x4 balancer that fit in space between my trains? You have only 2 width of free space...

I like my chaos <3 it's good xd

:c....

[jodokus31]

:: If item count less / more for each wagon
atm. we have condition to check for full/empty or item amount in cargo... but its not enough :/...
Lets say that we have 1-2 and one wagon is empty but second is full... in this situation without balancer half of our smelters do nothing...

This mod could help you to read the cargo wagons separately:
https://mods.factorio.com/mod/Inventory%20Sensor

Why u bully me so much silk T,T u probably hate me T-T

Can you give me 4x4 balancer that fit in space between my trains? You have only 2 width of free space...

I like my chaos <3 it's good xd

:c....

I think you don't need to take this personally. It's just easier to handle, if you follow some formalities. At least, you took the template this time

[Klonan]

While playtesting recently, I was irritated at having to build fuelling at every train stop,
But i didn't want every train to go to a refuel all the time, when it might not need fuel,
And even worse, with the train limits it could go to refuel, and then be stuck there waiting for the destination to open


So I made a mod which adds special signals you can put in the train stop name, which will skip depending on certain conditions:
https://mods.factorio.com/mod/Train_Control_Signals

[Amarula]

So I made a mod

Awesome!

[5thHorseman]

So I made a mod which adds special signals you can put in the train stop name, which will skip depending on certain conditions:
https://mods.factorio.com/mod/Train_Control_Signals

Brilliant. Just like many of the rest of your mods it's simple and straightforward and it should be stock, but you know better than I why it's not

Insta-install.

[ssilk]

Why u bully me so much silk T,T u probably hate me T-T

You’re ok. But your posts aren’t. As webmaster it’s part of my job to help making good posts.

Can you give me 4x4 balancer that fit in space between my trains? You have only 2 width of free space...

You have built it, you can change it. There is the destruction-tool, make a blueprint, remove it, rebuilt it shifted, voillá: free space. That’s what Factorio is about: it’s a puzzle to find a solution for the problems you made.

I like my chaos <3 it's good xd

So why do you want to change it?

So I made a mod

Nice. I remember some mod in 0.12 that had a similar way to propose refueling (need to put “refuel” into the station name).
This is much more clever. From programmers standpoint I don’t like it, because you misuse a name for a hidden function. But as mod it’s really ok to do it so.
And from players standpoint I miss, that you can’t use it with LTN.

[PanTobi]

Spoiler

:: If item count less / more for each wagon
atm. we have condition to check for full/empty or item amount in cargo... but its not enough :/...
Lets say that we have 1-2 and one wagon is empty but second is full... in this situation without balancer half of our smelters do nothing...

This mod could help you to read the cargo wagons separately:
https://mods.factorio.com/mod/Inventory%20Sensor

Why u bully me so much silk T,T u probably hate me T-T

Can you give me 4x4 balancer that fit in space between my trains? You have only 2 width of free space...

I like my chaos <3 it's good xd

:c....

I think you don't need to take this personally. It's just easier to handle, if you follow some formalities. At least, you took the template this time

xDD im not taking this personally xD i was just trolling gosh ...
i didnt know about this Mod <3 gonna try it soon <3 ty <3

Why u bully me so much silk T,T u probably hate me T-T

You’re ok. But your posts aren’t. As webmaster it’s part of my job to help making good posts.

Bfff... webmaster T_T...
just weeb xD !...

But i rly like colors :c...
Colors looks cool T_T... and amazing... and beauty T_T...

@klonan - why ping is not working lol... thats how u ping ppl everywhere T_T...
Anywaa... But u are Factorio Dev right?... because u have Pink Name... idk...

so why Mod? instead of Game Feature, i dont understand ...
ofc. gonna download ur mod soon and test how it works <3

//Edit:

@Ssilk
Yes i know... Factorio is about puzzle etc. and i rly like this... but some things are just IMPOSSIBLE to make :c...
Im big fan of building something small and packed... but sometimes i have to pick between Size or Speed...

and if i have to waste another 3 blocks width for only 20% Speed Bonus... its not worth xD

Some of my crazy and amazing builds: ( lol )

FarradusRafineryV.3

s1.png (178.57 KiB) Viewed 3153 times

Plastic4Line

s1.png (372.29 KiB) Viewed 3153 times

Raw2RC

s1.png (399.23 KiB) Viewed 3153 times

Steel800Furnances

s1.png (354.37 KiB) Viewed 3153 times

StartBaseMK2

s1.png (600.56 KiB) Viewed 3153 times

Start Base MK2 is mix of
- Early game Lab ( Sp1/2 )
- Power Production ( pipes, engines )
- Base building ( ins, belts, drills, asms )
and look how small and packed it is

[ssilk]

@Ssilk
Yes i know... Factorio is about puzzle etc. and i rly like this... but some things are just IMPOSSIBLE to make :c...
Im big fan of building something small and packed... but sometimes i have to pick between Size or Speed...

I recommend to look into the viewforum.php?f=8 Show your creations board.

There are really crazy people with the same sense for perfectionism as you. And some find absolutely crazy solutions to problems, that where formerly be told as unsolvable.

[Kalanndok]

While playtesting recently, I was irritated at having to build fuelling at every train stop,
But i didn't want every train to go to a refuel all the time, when it might not need fuel,
And even worse, with the train limits it could go to refuel, and then be stuck there waiting for the destination to open


So I made a mod which adds special signals you can put in the train stop name, which will skip depending on certain conditions:
https://mods.factorio.com/mod/Train_Control_Signals

Thank you, that is exactly what I was looking for on how to do it and could not come up with a solution in vanilla.
However, there seems to be a bug that can make a train skip a station that is neither refuel nor depot.