3 players, 2 in LAN, one over internet.
When 3rd players connects to the game, the 2nd is kicked.
When 2nd player connects, it says "Player __1__ joined the game",
when 3rd player connects, it`s also "Player __1__ joined the game". At that moment, the 2nd player is "dropped from the game".
All players are displayed with their correct multiplayer names using "/players".
It doesn`t matter who is player 1,2 or 3. Player 2 and 3 can`t connect at the same time anyway.
Problem is reproducable in win x32 and x64 client.
Anyone else facing this problem?
Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
I've just seen someone else having the __1__ problem, it was language related (german), changing to english client fixed the error, but not the disconnects.
Are you forwarding both ports the LAN players use in your router?
Are you forwarding both ports the LAN players use in your router?
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Yeah too bad, german or english makes no difference... still the 2nd player gets kicked.
What do you mean with "both" ports? TCP and UDP? They`re both forwarded.
What do you mean with "both" ports? TCP and UDP? They`re both forwarded.
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Do you get the same error message in German though?
What I meant by forwarding, do you forward a different port to both the LAN players, can't use the same port for 2 clients.
What I meant by forwarding, do you forward a different port to both the LAN players, can't use the same port for 2 clients.
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Me and my mates have been having the same problem tonight.
Works perfectly with 2 players but as soon as another joins, the second player(not the host) gets kicked from the game.
We've tried over a VPN also so don't think it's a port issue. Lots have been opened in preparation.
Anyone managed to play multiple players(more than 2) without any issues?
Works perfectly with 2 players but as soon as another joins, the second player(not the host) gets kicked from the game.
We've tried over a VPN also so don't think it's a port issue. Lots have been opened in preparation.
Anyone managed to play multiple players(more than 2) without any issues?
"To the optimist, the glass is half full. To the pessimist, it's half empty. To the engineer, the glass is twice the size it needs to be"
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
yeah, we (and i've seen others as well) have been playing for 8 hours without problems with 3 people, but right after i left someone else joined and desyncs happened, so maybe it's just some people with something wrong somewhere (happy debugging devs! 
)
)Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Well I'm glad to hear some folk have managed it with success. As you say, it may be something to do with one of the guys who was joining. He's got shared/dodgy internet sometimes.
Heres some debug info for the devs or anyone that can understand it, me not being one of those
34503.284044 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(0) username(Axm).
34503.284084 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(1) username(Ric666).
34503.284095 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284111 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284128 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284138 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:816: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) starting mapAlign
34503.284150 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:333: changing mapAlign state from(NotAligned) to(Aligning)
34503.284165 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:773: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) adding mapAlignTask(MapUploadAlignTask peer(2))
34503.284189 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:773: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) adding mapAlignTask(RemovePlayerAlignTask)
34503.286776 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.286823 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.286940 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.294217 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.311058 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.331075 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.343028 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.366704 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.366742 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.396214 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.407263 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.427592 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.431482 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.451735 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.479690 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.479981 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.511801 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.511863 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.548381 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.560348 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.580593 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.580634 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.612905 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.613024 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.648478 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.660569 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.677405 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.677447 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.713795 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.718011 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:511: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) received MapAlignAction from peer(0), mapTickForAligning(1237180) appliedTickClosuresCount(0)
34503.718039 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:461: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) received mapAlignStateChanged peerID(2) mapAlignState(NotAligning)
34503.718114 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:917: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) mapAlign finished targetTick(1237180) updating map and running the tasks ...
34503.718138 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:933: NetworkTick(7768) MapTick(1237180) resuming map.
34503.718202 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:333: changing mapAlign state from(Aligning) to(AlignedRunningTasks)
34503.725798 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.745339 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.761744 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.790597 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.790642 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.815392 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.815427 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.845492 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.858280 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.878490 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.878991 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.914913 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.914944 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.946681 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.946998 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.978561 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.978705 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.010825 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.010864 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.047220 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.059379 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.095617 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.095674 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.116065 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.116238 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.147452 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.159727 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.179543 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.179671 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.193708 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:323: MultiplayerManager changing state from(InGame) to(InGameSendingMap)
34504.193730 Notice C:\Factorio\src\Net/TransferSource.cpp:30: Serving file C:/Users\Axm\AppData\Roaming\Factorio\temp\mp-download.zip for peer 2
34504.215802 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.215830 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.223615 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/NetworkInputHandler.cpp:330: expectedMapTick(1237180) removing peer(1) success(true).
Heres some debug info for the devs or anyone that can understand it, me not being one of those
34503.284044 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(0) username(Axm).
34503.284084 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(1) username(Ric666).
34503.284095 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284111 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284128 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:659: Received peer info for pere(2) username(Harbinger).
34503.284138 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:816: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) starting mapAlign
34503.284150 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:333: changing mapAlign state from(NotAligned) to(Aligning)
34503.284165 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:773: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) adding mapAlignTask(MapUploadAlignTask peer(2))
34503.284189 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:773: networkTick(7755) mapTick(1237180) adding mapAlignTask(RemovePlayerAlignTask)
34503.286776 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.286823 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.286940 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.294217 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.311058 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.331075 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.343028 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.366704 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.366742 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.396214 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.407263 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.427592 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.431482 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.451735 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.479690 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.479981 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.511801 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.511863 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.548381 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.560348 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.580593 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.580634 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.612905 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.613024 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.648478 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.660569 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.677405 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.677447 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.713795 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.718011 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:511: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) received MapAlignAction from peer(0), mapTickForAligning(1237180) appliedTickClosuresCount(0)
34503.718039 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:461: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) received mapAlignStateChanged peerID(2) mapAlignState(NotAligning)
34503.718114 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:917: networkTick(7768) mapTick(1237180) mapAlign finished targetTick(1237180) updating map and running the tasks ...
34503.718138 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:933: NetworkTick(7768) MapTick(1237180) resuming map.
34503.718202 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:333: changing mapAlign state from(Aligning) to(AlignedRunningTasks)
34503.725798 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.745339 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.761744 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.790597 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.790642 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.815392 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.815427 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.845492 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.858280 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.878490 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.878991 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.914913 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.914944 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.946681 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.946998 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.978561 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34503.978705 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.010825 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.010864 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.047220 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.059379 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.095617 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.095674 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.116065 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.116238 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.147452 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.159727 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.179543 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.179671 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.193708 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/MultiplayerManager.cpp:323: MultiplayerManager changing state from(InGame) to(InGameSendingMap)
34504.193730 Notice C:\Factorio\src\Net/TransferSource.cpp:30: Serving file C:/Users\Axm\AppData\Roaming\Factorio\temp\mp-download.zip for peer 2
34504.215802 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.215830 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/Router.cpp:245: Received messageType(6) from unknown peer(1)
34504.223615 Info C:\Factorio\src\Net/NetworkInputHandler.cpp:330: expectedMapTick(1237180) removing peer(1) success(true).
"To the optimist, the glass is half full. To the pessimist, it's half empty. To the engineer, the glass is twice the size it needs to be"
Re: Character name (?) problem with 3 players
Hello this problem should have been fixed in previous version, let us know if this still happens in 0.11.6 (that is released today).