[Posila] [0.16.36] Restart regenerates the map layout.

[redcrate]

Hello,

After spending a lot of time regenerating maps to find one I like, I began to play, I did not like some of the paths I had chosen and figured why not just restart.

Unfortunately, restarting also regenerated the map instead of just starting me at the beginning of the same map and with starting resources.
I am unsure if this also changed the basic/resource/terrain/advanced settings I had chosen, or just the map layout.

My expected behavior of what restart would do is that it would preserve the map layout and settings and start you with the starting game resources/tech like in campaign play.

This occurs in both new game and scenario play.

Thank you,
Andy

[Dominik]

I agree, it also surprised me.

[Bilka]

Restarting does preserve the settings except for the seed, just like clicking regenerate in the map preview.

Opinion ahead: The point of restarting is that you get a new map. Otherwise you cant tell people with island spawns to just click restart. If you want the exact same map, just copy the map exchange string and generate a map with that.

[Klonan]

Before the map preview, this was sort of nice behaviour, as you could just hit 'restart' and it would roll another seed

I suppose now it is not necessary to work like this, I would not be against changing this behaviour to restarting the same seed

[Zavian]

Well even if everything looks good from the map preview, you can still have an unplayable island spawn. eg

[Jap2.0]

Why not both ?

[mrvn]

The restart could open the map preview with the current seed, Then if you didn't like it you click regenrate at the bottom for a new seed. Or you hit "Play again" (relabel the generate button) to play the same map again.

[Loewchen]

I would argue that restarting to get another seed is still way more common than restarting to get another try with the exact same map.

[kitcat]

Offering the choices “New map”, “Same map” and “Cancel” should be pretty simple, I think.

[Aeternus]

Roundabout way to solve it but you can view the map seed from any save I believe (at work so can't check). Then enter that seed into he map generator and you -should- get the same map again.

[mrvn]

Roundabout way to solve it but you can view the map seed from any save I believe (at work so can't check). Then enter that seed into he map generator and you -should- get the same map again.

You have to save the current map, quit the map, go to load map, copy the map seed, cancel, go to new game, paste map seed and then generate the map.

Certainly much more work than a "Restart this map" button.

[posila]

The thing is, I think generating with new seed is more useful for button in the pause menu, but I acknowledge the label is misleading and the most people will think it will start over the exact same map. Especially since that is what happens in campaign and scenarios with pregenerated map.

[mrvn]

I think both cases are valid. But playing the same map again is way harder to do than playing a new map with the same settings. For the later you just quit, new game, generate. Not sure if that needs a shortcut.

[eradicator]

Before the map preview, this was sort of nice behaviour, as you could just hit 'restart' and it would roll another seed

I suppose now it is not necessary to work like this, I would not be against changing this behaviour to restarting the same seed

You could make it a setting (possibly hidden in the config) "randomize-map-seed-on-restart=false".

[Rseding91]

Moved to Not a bug. That's what "Restart" is built to do: re-generate the map with the same settings but a new seed.

[mrvn]

We still want a "play this map again" option though.

[Rseding91]

We still want a "play this map again" option though.

That's what the map exchange string is for.

[epr]

Personally, I would prefer the "Restart" option to keep the same map seed with an additional "Regenerate" button.

[mrvn]

We still want a "play this map again" option though.

That's what the map exchange string is for.

That requires saving, quiting, going into the load dialog, copying the map exchange string, going back, starting new game, copy the map exchange string and hitting generate.

Way too complex for something people expect the "restart" button to do in the first place.

[eradicator]

If the GUI is being updated anyway, why not add an extra option to the already existant confirmation dialoge when restarting?

dialogue.png (70.3 KiB) Viewed 5786 times