Friday Facts #246 - The GUI update (Part 3)

[zerohourrct]

If the back button now scraps changes, it should be renamed to something like Cancel or Undo, and not back, so as not to conflict with veteran knowledge that 'back' = confirm.

[5thHorseman]

New resource system confirmed?

fff-246-mapgen-preview-02-tooltips.png

Far more likely just a mistake in the mock-up. Especially considering this screen doesn't have them:

pic

[Speadge]

soundsettings:

there is no "cancel" as describen in the text to see on the screenshot... as wenn its said "escabe is same as pressing back" but its not said if this means settings are saved or not

[Cazadore]

one little thing i miss from the preview screen:

A highlighted area for the starting zone, nothing fancy, just a green coloured box showing it. then the preview screen would be perfect.

[SirLANsalot]

I love even the mockups of the UI....hell even if they are "WIP" they look amazing....I want!

[eradicator]

Cool !
Setting the frequency to minimum gives you very few ore, setting the size to minimum gives you no ore at all. How does one makes the difference between very few and none at all with the new sliders ?

THIS. I do like that you don't need two clicks to change a setting, but I dislike the lack of explanatory *visible* text.

Difference between "very few" and "none" was exactly the thing i was going to say too. Looks good otherwise =).
______

I have a request -- currently the Map Exchange string is copy-able to the clipboard. Could you make it so that we can save it to a preset of our own? [...]

We were looking into it. Unfortunately the interface was getting pretty complicated with a lot of gotchas. So in the interest of time we decided to keep it simple and keep new features to a minimum.

Being able to directly select an old savegame for preset extraction would also be kinda nice. For the mean time i'm pretty sure mods can add presets. Not exactly comfortable to make a new mod for that, but...

[Oktokolo]

What it's elevated is what I call editable display (fancy, I know).

Yeah, fancy name for a button. For me, they look like buttons. For others they seem to look like buttons. You will either have to tell users that this buttons are not buttons - or just make them not look like buttons. This will probably be one of the first fixes after the new GUI gets released. You might even get feature requests for making the numbers directly editable by including a text field...

I hope this twisted explanation helps to understand a bit better.

We here in the forum are the power users and understand what you say. But if you like to explain users that buttons are not buttons if they feature rounded corners...
Well, it does not matter much in this case, because they will just use the sliders next to the buttons and map creation is not that frequent a task anyway.

[zac50333]

The UI looks great!

However I do have a problem with the slider bars. Whenever I've used a slider bar, they've always seemed imprecise. I much prefer it to have a description (none, very small, small, etc) than a slider bar. If there is a tooltip (one that appears by your mouse) that does show a description, then that's fine. If there isn't maybe there could be an option to turn that on, or have an option to switch out the sliders with the drop down boxes like weave right now.

Other than that, it really looks good and will be a step up from the current one.

[HalfPastZulu]

I'm calling it now: With the new GUI tileset, nobody will know if a value can be changed because the button and editable field look exactly the same. Notice the seed field for example, it looks exactly the same as the other buttons, making me wonder if it's a button, or a text field.

At a quick non-interactive glance it may appear that way at first. However, after comparing a couple different screens you realize that text boxes are rounded and buttons are square.

[Nova]

Please give me numbers for the sound settings! I don't want to frickle with the setting and have them "nearly the same" because I can't see if they are aligned. I want to see at what value they are and maybe even set the to precise ones. Especially when I change them for something and then change them back. I don't want to have to guess at what value they were, I want to exactly place them at the same value as before.

[Nemoricus]

Will there be a way to save custom presets in the game itself? IE, without having to copy a string and saving it to an external file?

[Tynach]

I'm calling it now: With the new GUI tileset, nobody will know if a value can be changed because the button and editable field look exactly the same. Notice the seed field for example, it looks exactly the same as the other buttons, making me wonder if it's a button, or a text field.

At a quick non-interactive glance it may appear that way at first. However, after comparing a couple different screens you realize that text boxes are rounded and buttons are square.

Tabs are also rounded, though. Personally, I think text boxes should be square with a lighter (perhaps even white) background - or at the very least they should look 'pressed in' rather than 'popped out'.

[Trax.Beaumont]

The map preview is great in general. But one thing I've always missed when I was starting a new session: The player spawn point. I think this should show up in the preview as well.

[Koub]

Why different types of "on/off / checkboxes" styles ?

Why

Factorio - why different checkboxes.jpg (110.9 KiB) Viewed 7265 times

[rtssmkn]

Instead of placing the map preview to the right of the dialog, why not keep the dialog in place and instead put the map as a full screen backdrop? See mock below.

The dialog will then be hidden whenever the user moves the mouse outside of the dialog area and it will be shown again whenever the user moves the mouse over the title at the top of the screen.

1.

fff-246-mapgen-01.png (305.96 KiB) Viewed 7259 times

2.

fff-246-mapgen-02.png (396.57 KiB) Viewed 7259 times

[Dev-iL]

As always, nice work on the UI update. It feels like something that can genuinely improve the game experience!

Onto more pressing issues... Since this GUI redesign phase is probably the last opportunity to add something fundamental to the way the UI is drawn, I urge you once more to improve the support for RTL languages.

You have already discussed how you're thinking about modifying the UI to suit colorblind players, bet let us not forget that they are but a small portion of all players, nowhere near the combined amount of potential players from the Arabic speaking countries, Iran, Israel, Pakistan, etc.

You have several courses of action here:

• Assign the manpower and fix it properly (I can elaborate on what needs fixing) in a matter of several days.
• "Dirty fix" by means of reversing the entire UI when the RTL flag is on (see example from MS below).
• Keep everything the way it is and ship a game that is embarrassingly unpolished for some players.
• Remove the ability to play the game in RTL languages and tell tens of thousands of potential players that you're not interested in them.

[xng]

Sliders instead of dropdowns! This makes my old heart so happy! <3

[eradicator]

You have several courses of action here:

• Assign the manpower and fix it properly (I can elaborate on what needs fixing) in a matter of several days.

Just out of curiosity because some of my mods have GUIs. Is the $proper_fix even remotely automatable? Or would i have to redesign every GUI twice? Because as a "solo modder" i don't have the manpower to do everything twice, and i doubt most of the others have :x.

[Bilka]

If the back button now scraps changes, it should be renamed to something like Cancel or Undo, and not back, so as not to conflict with veteran knowledge that 'back' = confirm.

Seems like this is alrady being done, but I also want to stress that this is very important to make clear.

Tabs are also rounded, though. Personally, I think text boxes should be square with a lighter (perhaps even white) background - or at the very least they should look 'pressed in' rather than 'popped out'.

+1 to giving them another color if you dont want to change the button look at all. Just a way to make more clear that it's NOT a button.

Why different types of "on/off / checkboxes" styles ?

Oh god, the things you dont see at first glance... please please use only checkbox or only slider.

[dee-]

Thank you for the mockups.

However I am not as happy as others seem to be with the outcome so far. For me it looks all over the place, riddled with inconsistencies and very "busy".

details