13.x train loading design

Don't know how to use a machine? Looking for efficient setups? Stuck in a mission?
Post Reply
vanatteveldt
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
Posts: 930
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2015 11:44 am
Contact:

13.x train loading design

Post by vanatteveldt »

[Is there already a post/guide about train (un)loading in 13.x? I searched but couldn't really find something, sorry if I missed it!]

AFAIK, in 12.x the main train loading design options were a (a) 6 logistic chests with fast inserters into the wagon, or (b) an n-to-6 belt splitter with fast inserters into steel chests into the wagon. In 13.x, logistic bots became more expensive while the stack inserters are a much improved way to load from belts. So, it seems that it is might be viable to revisit the inserter train loading design.

It seems to me that a much simpler design of a 1-to-4 double splitter to 4 stack inserters buffered with 4 steel chests suffices for a pretty high throughput:

Image

What design do you use nowadays?

(related question: Do we have numbers on how many stack inserters can fully saturate/empty green/red/blue belts, and/or the number of items per second stack inserters can move to/from containers and belts? )

User avatar
siggboy
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
Posts: 988
Joined: Tue Mar 29, 2016 11:47 am
Contact:

Re: 13.x train loading design

Post by siggboy »

Reddit is currently full with train loading and unloading stations:

https://i.imgur.com/3bQ5Oi1.png

https://imgur.com/gallery/67i08

They're probably the best two for unloading. The first one has 100% compression, the second one only ~98%, but the second one is more compact, but also uglier.

I'd probably go with the first one.

For loading you should use the smart loader with a combinator, but you can load more belts now, so some splitters are needed to saturate the smart loader (if you have the input).
(related question: Do we have numbers on how many stack inserters can fully saturate/empty green/red/blue belts, and/or the number of items per second stack inserters can move to/from containers and belts? )
4 stack inserters can saturate a blue belt (with some excess throughput even).

1 stack inserter moves about 800 units/minute to a belt at full tech (a little less, I don't know the exact number right now, just measured that with a counter; I think it's something like 770/minute).

Edit: The stack inserter can move 766 items per minute at full tech (from a chest to an express belt).
Is your railroad worrying you? Doctor T-Junction recommends: Smart, dynamic train deliveries with combinator Magick

oisyn
Manual Inserter
Manual Inserter
Posts: 3
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2016 8:07 pm
Contact:

Re: 13.x train loading design

Post by oisyn »

Sorry to kick this old thread, but since this post is referred to by the Factorio wiki page of the stack inserter:
siggboy wrote:Reddit is currently full with train loading and unloading stations:
Edit: The stack inserter can move 766 items per minute at full tech (from a chest to an express belt).
I was wondering how you got to those numbers, because I'm seeing different things (in 0.15.30 though, so maybe things have changed in the mean time, but I don't think so). I'm measuring ticks between swings of an inserter using circuits, and I found that a stack inserter taking a full stack (12 items) from a chest and dropping them on an (empty) belt pulses every 58 ticks.

Or more generally, for the fast inserter family (includes stack, filter and stack filter):
chest to chest, or chest to belt with a stack size of 1: 26 ticks
chest to belt with a stack size of n (with n > 1): 3n + 22 ticks

Here's a blueprint of my test setup. Basically just an inserter that pulses its contents, a tick counter that resets every pulse, and a memory cell that records the number of ticks between pulses. Note: this blueprint requires the Creative Mode mod.

So, with 58 ticks per transfer, that boils down to 60 ticks per second / 58 ticks * 60 second per minute * 12 items per transfer ≈ 744,83 items per minute.

.edit: I confirmed that it is indeed approximately 744 items per minute by counting the number of items traveling on the belt and dividing by time.

Post Reply

Return to “Gameplay Help”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users