data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8b927/8b9277910717ec2b4ac953f8ac38790db2a3deee" alt="Image"
The top combinator was placed by hand, then copied and pasted via the use of blueprints to create the bottom combinator. Despite having the exact same settings the light for the bottom combinator is not on.
Saving the game then loading it will cause the bottom combinator's light to turn on, as will manually turning the combinator off and then on again.
Edit: Changed image URL.