Smart Furnace - load-balanced, demand-based, and tileable

[MeduSalem]

AFAIK Stack Inserters can grab 12 items at once and normal inserter can grab 3 (botch fully upgraded). When both work simultaneously we get 15 stack bonus that can be used for steel production. For stone we can use only stack inserter with 12 stack bonus.

On weekend I will try to build smart furnace based on this idea.

Weird... In 0.13.6 the Stack Inserters grab 13 items when fully upgraded... Don't know why, but they definitely grab 13 (1 base + 12 bonus) and not 12. Maybe 0.13.6 has changed the stack size once more...

Otherwise I would have tried the 12+3=15 combination for Steel (albeit quite the contraption compared to how easy it was back in 0.12) and also used the Stack Inserter for Stone.

inserter bonus.png (251.09 KiB) Viewed 4633 times

[Neotix]

That sux ;/
To be honest I feel like devs with v0.13 decided that all in v0.12 was too easy so they fucked up everything. For me it's the most disappointing update so far.

[MeduSalem]

That sux ;/
To be honest I feel like devs with v0.13 decided that all in v.12 was too easy so they fucked up everything. For me it's the most disappointing update so far.

Well... truer words haven't been spoken... relating to the "0.12 was too easy so they fucked up everything".

That said I am not completely disappointed about 0.13. In comparison I personally found 0.12 a bit disappointing due to how the circuit network stuff was implemented only half-assed back then and how we had to wait almost another year for that to get "fixed" and still some items lack the connection. I for example miss the ability to switch Beacons on/off on signal.


So when it comes to smart furnaces (or smart factories eventually when they ever get to implement recipe switching on circuit network signal), they will have to fix the residual item issue somehow. Thinking more about it an option to manually override the Stack Bonus on a per inserter basis would only fix 1-resource-item-recipes anyways, and on the long term it wouldn't help with recipes requiring multiple resources.

Since a change/addition this dramatic won't happen before 0.14 or even 0.15 I guess in the meantime we can write smart furnaces including Steel/Stone off. It may not be completely impossible but the contraptions necessary to overcome the stack bonus effects defeat the purpose. Time to set up a dedicated spot for Steel... altough I am doing it only reluctantly.

[Neotix]

I almost build smart furnace but encounter one problem. I need combinators contraption that will store input signal and can be updated only when inserters don't hold any item.
It's crucial because if input will change while any inserter hold item then it will ruin the setup.

[MeduSalem]

XKnight can i ask for blueprint or explanation because i'm staring on it for a while and have no idea what you did.

Sure, why not.

blueprint

Input - left bottom combinator

Code: Select all

H4sIAAAAAAAA/81b7ZKjuA59la78vEvu4g9MqFmeZGorRSfubmoJpIDsTleq332dDvkQYGJZ9OzMv0xjoSMd68hysq2eimqTFU/r9KjLNm9z3aTHY5ntdLrY
VGXTZmW73FS757zM2qpeBPuqMU9VZXr8kS7j4D1dio/APFnqzem/zervC7b4Mz2+1lqbp85m39f5No2DTV5vDnl7+sA+zL/gJS9aXZ9e2eSvZVakx/Z9b179
d163h6xYBGdPzn9cPhcHvTi97VC2KQ+DvNzqHyk7mQqcfVYTPtd6a/eYUz2WPJGJUqtEXTxHOS4Qjq+ojn9mr+d5zJPo6nngZCa8mmDdSoXBzFH8iozh2yfG
3emWt3p38fw5a/LNMi8bXZtnb/4rK/T71UVVvi7fMvPkdsRG3NngkzZesqYdWbzqFovJxc0uq8dWJ91q+Wh1USx1YYJdmyjsq2Jkw0WYFE6xdphC6Zymf6pq
q8vl5k037YBk0znK66q/kDslpmm1LnorBSIrcKV0y4iJaPaqlybIf12XRtdMTC09M7mts7LZV+b1z7q4vV1d9+NDKlosXMgcT1rQP/a1bhqbkQupV2gky7Yy
VcoY2V6NXTieYDGN2GJXeQk98I0ZZDe9eoy12Rd5CzbwhaLMoXgMV19oyqZ5ekEzNHBhK5um6/OhLnU9Un+uynFfPbI6b992ujWA7Xr9/+hUQkzQtnl9riBm
u6LVm0FxECcvvi+4o+qb123z7m03p9PjS1437dpFCXW2efuMxrlepmFQ7XWdfcJZ/LYIqkO7P7iZ6rTZL44cH0fVE9JgWLfZRDg5iLyCwQ1sTQubN+6NPply
WtH1bHfp+R8qPec3IrMjvLMzYKstDwLugPDXiPal0bwL9+9fH+7Qu6gM42aLN3wSUp3JmQIe4qLNYKRxdYf5htmD1St77BLXBCQT8R85HMyTjDkKfAgCvdWb
fGs01XpI8ucyn1DIyKHqY9bb9wmfyFM0rcVdbL62RLHPtO72WX0Kfrr4w6M+GQP79/VnL7R+qavdOi+NgVO7VjR6gc+2x5aarEfscbbl9Ap7ftkvkMPwZ+bQ
bXDG3EY5/e4LPcq5zWBWyOkNG6wcnj3GV/LBKVdg4hOa8IRu4Umok66bq5yNzOXc9mPosR0dtpz/JrvfqlL8N3uO/8w9d55cFdlu39tq7EQm7kYmthpEqovq
eKQmB1JdHyBADFJ3nx1HvTyc32fu4XOCCLOCUpL4I+jN8ggxX6Focu8/H2qas//9kSIBQOLOGRZDAMMGmJgAHwKtUJwH/g9PU9QE+ACIEQxKIIBhhXYH0Bst
Exik3AFwKDE8pmSgN+EmIIgRHILnFR7NngIfDikEANiQc4J22VLgg0AiSATLkCAome2igsClCAEEzta48gdivbQhInElFbxE5QRpfoTEl1yuSKBIC4JIPyCX
DxCBIBfslgRBrCcu4wj04u5YBBRuQRBuhztBAiaBIBrUckHQ8sf58eEad8cioKyLmQvZeH58MDEE56DQC4LQP7469qcc4pgqoPILQpF2ur6mnGQR3IMiKggt
pXOePKiHOJoLWLklob/B5MkDFKaEw3I3MlzCpQl81cCfaZiCsJqtIIx8WYMGwZVZsHOWhJ7ADsGTR44QJGwFJLUsz4QAcXyRsGBJQsEa+9qMP5EQzWVvL0jc
9Ru6fM20UxDHAAkPNJJyoLEnyYNoiA5Twg5GErrmqUR4gEBMjCQsWRGhZFm/ZOvPKMRhv7dHJLlHngkCYnQkoYZHBA1/lAsPUiHGFRJ2wpIwA7PnwgMC4jIh
gps7osyyh9/99qcTYpotYZ8bUed4MyFAXChEUMoj8jB4Jh4h5tkSKnlEnXfNhABxLRiFcyZh9HcM/mRC3K5FvL+j7z/GXwfLa5ByOs9KR2CEDtd21cw8fE4Q
LvdKE0Egxm86ffxfoUIO/Ce0r5abTh8AMQIALEuKoA2WazYfAAoBAPZKitC32q7ZfBBE7ggUrKuKoAyP7nR8kEgEEtgrKersaV4gAgGk96OIGU5082LhCCyw
d1LkcZrLjNMHE0NggpqtCGc851m0BySEdis4B1EEIcTMoj1AYagHxSWmHjzGpiIeCDBEg/2JoswQrYNcDwiIohxDeYkp8mKfsHlgwNRj2GapGW7UZkoEolOJ
oajEBFF5NNXxAIJpWGDLFZNvN2aCgOjb41kPfZaBggcEROcew2YrpjZbMyFAHP7iWac6UyfvERwfQb75fMex+1FBZ2n8d3PG0e4XFsEAvrH1rdatqY1P62+6
3P4LFZpzmrVFAAA=

*Edit: fixed const array in blueprint

Hey XKnight, may I ask if you could update the blueprint string back from page 2 (the load balancing thingy) to 0.13? Or anyone else who still has this setup and already moved over to 0.13?

Because if I load that string in 0.13 basically all the constant combinators are empty and I have no clue what values should go where...

[XKnight]

Hey XKnight, may I ask if you could update the blueprint string back from page 2 (the load balancing thingy) to 0.13? Or anyone else who still has this setup and already moved over to 0.13?

Updated to 0.13.8.

Video

Blueprint

Code: Select all

H4sIAAAAAAAA/8Vb226jSBD9lYjHXbxL38DWLA+5fcVoZRHobFrCYOH2aCKLf1+wMXYzAZedqsy8JfZp+5w6VV1VYbLyLi/TJL9bxjtdWGON3sS7XZGsdOyl
ZbGxSWFnabl6MUViy8rz1+WmeVdZxLufceC/xzNZ+5mpdLr/JfcbkK3KfPmi35Ifpqzi3avJra7aYzfmvyLJ4519XzfH/zCV3Sa55x8+7fDiLPDq5oxtYWPm
myLTP2NW+yAk65G8Q3IgkvdI0SEFECl6pOyQEoiUPVJ1SAVEqh4ZdsgQiAx7ZNQhIyAy6pHzDjkHIuc9ctEhF0Dk4uSE4GiFAIi9P2F7G0F99HDCHo3EoE56
PGGPVmJQLz2dsEczMaibnk/Yo52Yquv2l0VxyM0mAb97zPs33lU6a5Jxn+7vS5M1IU1NlW6NbX9gdfvP70pAUhn7ttLWpKNFYKb+Um0d4JfqwOmsZfNiZrov
9WqqjV1CSOokfdvzPJSlpvyUa10l+w/0/vT8cmvXW9hRL/lWe1B9hKuPf/bSoj3ju8cvwvitsoovl7Vx0Jmuf1yl6+EsoK586LsxJbmr5HkA5Oe8K75Y5I1u
4VdY9DwUf9OF4hevjoUi/JzeDL9WGKtXR+qmKovZOk+sHtP6/N1puW7E7d8PKCbjaKDOv8gH0tm1fHMJ3ig7ps1HZb+uPI8dA9RTjsukoFKr8TMmbsZMpyZr
4j/aGwOd3p1DUFYmrN586XVStV869v65oao0B6zfl/uGY/lalaulKZoD4tck3+jbmg7H4AwauvlElrDx6xcYu4vp8jWxG2TXb4/cRGmKJoI6EcZoPFQXZ9BZ
1IaK3TqETgi9n+qC0RFrMr3201kwOmSdYzdW63wA5UE/Zd3aS10jIUOT8CMyp4lkUocP1J8Y3S6qz8ZHt4tf+DS5AdVXn641F9X/mlozlOO3F5sIehVE41WJ
z52IbFZJns/yZLX+oJLw+gPtjyf32l8jfXDeE3FH09gDqsAknAGjZSBuZBDBGIQkMWAYMRj0FwpGSJEQ4jimcggBs0SReIzjeMxJewa3HD4hhkFIuBEKYYQk
ieUEhuWUS2gBIyRICEkMQnPXchxOCN9yEsFy3O3aObDKSRJCAiOHQpdQACPESSynMCy3cAkJGCFGQihEIMQH3RqwyjESy4UYOeRWOQ6scpyEkMIgFLiEYN1o
QOK4CMNx7r3KYb0pTQbNMfiEw3nn/EfhRk/C7EiTXnMMN7pt3nDRN0g9RwlYrQxIqEcY1OUw0BA+NHfZAsO4bigFrGOnaQfvEfgMUk3ACiVNN3iP4DfhFkoB
K5Q0F9kCI38GlRHWrtPMUw8YfnO7dQHr1mlWEo8YfNz6JmD1jWYj8YiRP259k7D6RjNMPWDwca9XAWvVaXZ6Txh+czt1AWuNaPbEzxh8YAlDsyZ+RjAYMENo
VnZPGBnituISuG5oIyJoF/fsxogA//SgSBhwHAZOSID7hZCEEMMgNHgEDrgBEiSEJAahQdIA/xIhSQgJDEJu3yyBW1RGQijEIOQ2zuqKLSo+IYVByL35JXwF
hM9njsBnMEkrdxBVsEEnIKEXYYRr0EjDGjWainePwEcNnlWEXbI06bTAiI+7aFOwNo6mZ3jEiI/bMyhYz0BzIT1g8HEXBQrWMtB0pc8YfOCTJz6BJwwCboeg
Dh1C7Zt0j5p4Yu3j571r0DN2ZzrV/f+Rq+tvlbbbqrhbftNF9j/8QfdSEzgAAA==

[MeduSalem]

Updated to 0.13.8.

[...]

Awesome, thanks! Didn't expect it that fast.

Even with an updated coder using virtual signals instead of item signals... nice.

[Acarin]

Just a quick thought to throw in to see if anyone can poke holes in my premise:

Several comments have been made about stack sizes and inability to generate a lock-free smart furnace as a consequence. If the Devs added furnaces into the circuit network, would we then be able to work around the issue?

It seems to me that if we could pull a signal off a furnace showing its current recipe, combinators (or possibly just filter inserters) could be programmed accordingly, and we could fix the locking issue. I have a feeling that it might not be too hard to implement the code either, given that tanks were recently added in a similar way...

[khoul]

Hey guys, first post here .

NOTE: This was tested with stack size 3, 4 and 5.
I think i found a solution for the stack size problem, the "issue" is that the inserters need to take the items from a belt, does not work from a chest, AND, they can't be already connected to a circuit network. (read below)

Stack size reset.png (747.23 KiB) Viewed 4398 times

The trick is to set the circuit condition [EVERYTHING=0 and READ HAND CONTENTS on HOLD ](as far as i tested it, the PULSE option works as well)
The inserter will grab 1 item, and reset itself by dropping that item.

If you want to just hook up 1 inserter, simply connect it to a powerpole.
If you want to hook up more, you can link them together to each other (tested with 3 inserters linked by red wire).

I hope i was able to help..