Zones for Better Factory Control

Post your ideas and suggestions how to improve the game.

Moderator: ickputzdirwech

Post Reply
Nexusuxen
Manual Inserter
Manual Inserter
Posts: 3
Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2018 1:38 pm
Contact:

Zones for Better Factory Control

Post by Nexusuxen »

TL;DR
The ability to select areas on the map to control certain behaviors for various mechanics.
What ?
Selecting areas on the map to create new 'zones', to then selectively adjust how your factory behaves in those areas. Bot pathing and changing how alerts work are the primary use cases for such a feature, but I'm sure more uses exist.
The following image is a quick edit I made of an old factory screenshot of mine, to visualize how the proposed mechanic would be employed.
factorio zones.png
factorio zones.png (527.54 KiB) Viewed 338 times
The red areas are zones designated 'No-Fly', where bots are not permitted to traverse through. I've drawn them such that bots will avoid biters and areas without roboports.

The dark blue areas designate a custom alert zone. In this instance, I'd disable alerts appearing for turrets engaging and most structures being damaged at my perimeter walls (namely walls and turrets). Thus, the alerts in the bottom of my screen wouldn't be clogged with unimportant alerts for a wall being gnawed on or a turret dealing with a stray biter. However, I'd still be alerted if something actually got destroyed! I'd also still get alerts if somehow biters snuck into my base and started gnawing at any of my leftover interior defenses, so I could take care of that immediately.
The following image is a mockup of how the custom zone UI might look like. I just stitched screenshots together from various UIs and icons :P (Also ignore the modded icons!)
factorio zone planner.png
factorio zone planner.png (28.33 KiB) Viewed 338 times
It's rudimentary, but the gist is that you'd give a zone a name and open its configuration menu, to then select buildings and corresponding alerts, and whether you want the selected alerts to never show up, or *only* the selected alerts to show up. Zones with the same name will share the same configuration, even if they're not connected.
In this example, turret-firing and building-damage alerts won't show up at all, leaving only building-destroyed, no-repair-packs, no-material-for-construction, no-storage, and not-enough-robot alerts showing up.

The light blue zones are areas where bots will prefer to path through. I've drawn them such that bots flying through there will always be near a roboport. (Granted with the robot AI changes detailed in FFF #374 this won't be as important, but still!)
Why ?
There are certain behaviors to the game that you have little to no control over, which range from a minor inconvenience to annoying to somewhat problematic. The ability to adjust how your factory behaves in specific areas would be quite helpful for alleviating some of these issues.

This is admittedly... not a terribly big deal? At least the use cases I've presented. However, creating zones within your factory for behavior control seems like a sensible addition. For instance, City: Skylines has a very similar mechanic, and it's vital for ensuring your city develops how you want it to! I'm also sure modders alone could find uses for this mechanic if it had enough flexibility to apply to more than just bots and alerts.

The main inspiration for this was actually DoshDoshington's first Rampant video! Specifically, this moment where he notes "If only there was a way to make alerts only sound for things you actually care about." https://youtu.be/FLbJMBM7QnM?si=82oB-OWg_sQthZjV&t=734

Qon
Smart Inserter
Smart Inserter
Posts: 2120
Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2016 6:27 am
Contact:

Re: Zones for Better Factory Control

Post by Qon »

If there were a zone concept in Factorio I could integrate it in my self building factory (with recursive blueprints+) if zone info was read and write accessible to combinator circuits. Then I could use the zones to easily tell the factory what parts shouldn't be expanded to, if I want to prioritize some area or do advanced deconstruction (deconstruction planner potentially leaves items stranded when roboports and electric poles at edges of the area get removed before the center etc) or upgrade of an area which require complete rebuilding. And long term expansion planning decisions that the factory makes could be seen on map.

Mods currently can't use the render API on the map view, so even if planner tools can be used and modded in to do some thing, without visual feedback it's sadly not really that great as a mod. Though I've asked for the render API to be expanded to map view so things like these could be made into mods (zones that is, the alert and bot zone avoidance functionality would be separate).

Post Reply

Return to “Ideas and Suggestions”