[0.16.x] Bob's Mods: General Discussion

[that_spruehing]

Can someone tell me How this new Oil Generator thing works?

[ukezi]

you pipe oil or oil products in and get power out. What did you expect?

[Ghostling]

hmmm Science have changed a lot. as it is now our giant factorie gone on halt because all the science recipes have changed back to vanilla. is there a fix for this so that we again have the complicated science or does we have to wait till the mods have been updated again? and is it a problem in Bob's mods or is it in Angel's? All for the love for you mod guys using so much time on this.

[gaelyte]

hmmm Science have changed a lot. as it is now our giant factorie gone on halt because all the science recipes have changed back to vanilla. is there a fix for this so that we again have the complicated science or does we have to wait till the mods have been updated again? and is it a problem in Bob's mods or is it in Angel's? All for the love for you mod guys using so much time on this.

It's strange, it didn't change for me.

[Ghostling]

hmmm Science have changed a lot. as it is now our giant factorie gone on halt because all the science recipes have changed back to vanilla. is there a fix for this so that we again have the complicated science or does we have to wait till the mods have been updated again? and is it a problem in Bob's mods or is it in Angel's? All for the love for you mod guys using so much time on this.

It's strange, it didn't change for me.

well, then i don't know if we laugh or cry. we are running Factorio version 16.36 with the newest versions of all Bob's and angels mods (from the ingame updater) plus some other mods Like Logistic Train Network Auto fill and some other.

can't select other than expensive science, but that's still vanilla.

[mtilsted]

hmmm Science have changed a lot. as it is now our giant factorie gone on halt because all the science recipes have changed back to vanilla. is there a fix for this so that we again have the complicated science or does we have to wait till the mods have been updated again? and is it a problem in Bob's mods or is it in Angel's? All for the love for you mod guys using so much time on this.

It's strange, it didn't change for me.

well, then i don't know if we laugh or cry. we are running Factorio version 16.36 with the newest versions of all Bob's and angels mods (from the ingame updater) plus some other mods Like Logistic Train Network Auto fill and some other.

can't select other han expensive science, but that's still vanilla.

Pretty sure it is not the science recipes which changed, but the transport belt which went back to vanilla. So now there is no more basic transport belt, so half my factorio is not connected any more, and express belts now again require lube, instead of cobalt steel.

Martin

[bobingabout]

but the transport belt which went back to vanilla. So now there is no more basic transport belt, so half my factorio is not connected any more, and express belts now again require lube, instead of cobalt steel.

Martin

Turn on Transport belt overhaul.


Logistics 0.16.19:
Deleted a problem migration script.
Cleaned up the description of some settings.
fixed offset green inserter base
Fixed green and purple belt cover alignment
Add coloured bot graphics by zombiee

[Pothrekr]

Hi Bob,

There is a conflict in Bob's Revamp with Bob's Power:

Bob's Revamp.PNG (15.38 KiB) Viewed 6530 times

The only mods enabled are Library, Power and Revamp.

Regards
Poth

[bobingabout]

Hi Bob,

There is a conflict in Bob's Revamp with Bob's Power:

Bob's Revamp.PNG

The only mods enabled are Library, Power and Revamp.

Regards
Poth

Hydrazine generator only checks if Revamp is installed to enable it.
Hydrazine on revamp itself has other checks to enable it.

I can see the issue. I'll fix it.

[Redstylt]

I was reporting the same error
Waiting the fix

[bobingabout]

I was reporting the same error
Waiting the fix

alright, looking into it now.

in the mean time.


Tech 0.16.5:
Changed science pack colour change default to false
Updated the locale entries for science pack remaining amount.

[mrvn]

I'm getting some crashes when trying to use the final two belt tiers with the upgrade planner mod.

This is what I get when I add any turbo or ultimate belt item (belts/undergrounds/splitters/loaders from loader redux mod)

(I tested every single one and it always says green underground belt in the error message, might be related?)

The first time my game crashed due to messing with upgrade planner I screenshotted this error message (it says green transport belt instead of underground belt), but I couldn't manage to reproduce it since then

It seems my quite innocent change has broken a few other mods that try to intergrate into my mods.

I've already explained why I did the change. I swapped green and purple belts around in tier.
but this one change seems to have broken... well, at least 4 mods. Mini loaders, Loader redux, ShinyBobGFX and Upgrade planner.

Honestly, these mods could have avoided breaking as hard as they did with a few additional checks... checking to see if the item it's editing or accessing exists before trying to use it, rather than doing a "Is mod installed?" check.
They would still need updating either way though.

I should probably contact the guys who make Mini loaders and Loader Redux, they might need to edit their higher tier loaders to match the new top end belt speeds (though it should work either way, because a loader running at 66.66ips will still interface properly to a 60ips belt, etc.)

Could this be just more loader redux problems? I'm playing with the new logistic options all enabled and upgrade planer works just fine for all tiers.

[bobingabout]

I'm getting some crashes when trying to use the final two belt tiers with the upgrade planner mod.

This is what I get when I add any turbo or ultimate belt item (belts/undergrounds/splitters/loaders from loader redux mod)

(I tested every single one and it always says green underground belt in the error message, might be related?)

The first time my game crashed due to messing with upgrade planner I screenshotted this error message (it says green transport belt instead of underground belt), but I couldn't manage to reproduce it since then

It seems my quite innocent change has broken a few other mods that try to intergrate into my mods.

I've already explained why I did the change. I swapped green and purple belts around in tier.
but this one change seems to have broken... well, at least 4 mods. Mini loaders, Loader redux, ShinyBobGFX and Upgrade planner.

Honestly, these mods could have avoided breaking as hard as they did with a few additional checks... checking to see if the item it's editing or accessing exists before trying to use it, rather than doing a "Is mod installed?" check.
They would still need updating either way though.

I should probably contact the guys who make Mini loaders and Loader Redux, they might need to edit their higher tier loaders to match the new top end belt speeds (though it should work either way, because a loader running at 66.66ips will still interface properly to a 60ips belt, etc.)

Could this be just more loader redux problems? I'm playing with the new logistic options all enabled and upgrade planer works just fine for all tiers.

as far as I can tell, it's an upgrade planner problem, and as far as I know, Klonan fixed it.

[bobingabout]

Power 0.16.4:
Added extra checks before adding hydrazine generator.
Given fluid generators their own category (line on the recipe screen)
Added steam engine MK4, and scaled everything to match. (Steam engine tiers now match Boiler tiers)
Boiler and Steam engine research unified into Steam power research (you'll have to research it again)

[steinio]

Power 0.16.4:
Added extra checks before adding hydrazine generator.
Given fluid generators their own category (line on the recipe screen)
Added steam engine MK4, and scaled everything to match. (Steam engine tiers now match Boiler tiers)
Boiler and Steam engine research unified into Steam power research (you'll have to research it again)

How are the ratios now?
1 boiler and 2 steam engines for every Mk?

[npuldon]

Think you might have a graphics bug:
https://imgur.com/a/QLZWZ

[Haphollas]

Power 0.16.4:
Added extra checks before adding hydrazine generator.
Given fluid generators their own category (line on the recipe screen)
Added steam engine MK4, and scaled everything to match. (Steam engine tiers now match Boiler tiers)
Boiler and Steam engine research unified into Steam power research (you'll have to research it again)

How are the ratios now?
1 boiler and 2 steam engines for every Mk?

The ratios should be easy to calculate:

(Boiler Energy consumption x Boiler Efficiency) / Steam Engine Power Output = max. supported engines per boiler

Steam Engine Liquid Consumption = Water needed for your boiler setup

[Karlito15]

I have an idea for the new belt overhaul: Make the belt speed part of the config.

You have done it for all the modules: in the ingame menu, it is possible to set every value for the module bonuses (speed per level, productivity per level, etc.)
It would be nice if the same would be possible for the belt speeds in your overhaul.
I myself really like the 12-based system of angels, and will keep it. (12 is a far nicer number then 10, from a mathmatical point of view)
If I have to, I will change the relevant numbers in the mod files themselves, and I am fine with it, but it would be much nicer to be able to set the speeds in the ingame mod options.

I know, this will be some work to implement, but maybe not as much as it sounds (? I don't really know), so it's absolutely your decision, I just want to put the idea out there.

Thanks for all the work, and greetings from Berlin!

[mexmer]

Power 0.16.4:
Added extra checks before adding hydrazine generator.
Given fluid generators their own category (line on the recipe screen)
Added steam engine MK4, and scaled everything to match. (Steam engine tiers now match Boiler tiers)
Boiler and Steam engine research unified into Steam power research (you'll have to research it again)

How are the ratios now?
1 boiler and 2 steam engines for every Mk?

The ratios should be easy to calculate:

(Boiler Energy consumption x Boiler Efficiency) / Steam Engine Power Output = max. supported engines per boiler

Steam Engine Liquid Consumption = Water needed for your boiler setup

not sure how is it after last update, but your formula is wrong.
you forgot about steam temperature.

mk2 boiler generates steam with lower temperature, than mk2 steam engine requires for maximum output.
same applied for mk3 and mk4
except first tier, all following tiers have different temperatures, so you never get 100% output from steam engine, and if you put mk2 steam engine after mk3 boiler, you start to be ineficient, because mk3 makes higher temperature steam, than mk2 engine needs.

it's similar situation for using regular boiler with steam turbina (nuclear), it works ... but you never get to 100% power output from it (although still better than feeding steam engines from nuclear reactor, because there is quite huge loss of efficiency, since steam engine consumes 165C steam, while reactor produces like 500C or something ... i'm lazy to check wiki)

then again, i have not played with last update, maybe @bobingabout also normalized steam temperatures.

[bobingabout]

Power 0.16.4:
Added extra checks before adding hydrazine generator.
Given fluid generators their own category (line on the recipe screen)
Added steam engine MK4, and scaled everything to match. (Steam engine tiers now match Boiler tiers)
Boiler and Steam engine research unified into Steam power research (you'll have to research it again)

How are the ratios now?
1 boiler and 2 steam engines for every Mk?

yes.

Formula is:
Power = water power per degree(0.2kW) * fluid per tick * 60 * (Water Temperature - 15) * effectivity

Stats of steam engines are:

Code: Select all

0.2kW * 0.5 * 60 * 150 =  900kW * 1     =  900kW   (SE1 with B1)
0.2kW * 0.6 * 60 * 220 = 1584kW * 1.066 = 1688.5kW (SE2 with B2)
0.2kW * 0.7 * 60 * 290 = 2436kW * 1.133 = 2760kW   (SE3 with B3)
0.2kW * 0.8 * 60 * 360 = 3456kW * 1.2   = 4147.2kW (SE4 with B4)

Divide the boiler's output by the first result (before steam engine's efficiency bonus is added) and you get the number of engines that boiler can support.
I purposely tweaked the numbers of boilers so it was double this consumption value, meaning every boiler should be able to supply for 2 steam engines.

Think you might have a graphics bug:
https://imgur.com/a/QLZWZ

ugh... and I was hoping to be done with Logistics.

I guess I'll look into it