Efficiency of Roundabouts vs Crossings for T-Junctions

[jameinel]

I've heard this has been contentious, and it was something I wanted to measure.

tl;dr: A single T-junction seems to be 13% more efficient than a roundabout (283 trips vs 251 in my testing.)

First off, tremendous thanks to viewtopic.php?f=18&t=18621 for making me realize my roundabout structure was wrong. (if you try to build a roundabout going into a 6-wide straight lines which is the "obvious" way with a circle, you end up with trains that have to go all the way around the loop to make the shortest turn).

So I set up a test scenario and have spent a couple of days now turning the counting and making sure my signal spacing are "optimal" at least as well as I can make them. I saved some blueprints of my circuits in case anyone wants to critique them. I can't actually fit them into a single screenshot, but I can make a couple of screenshots to show the basic layout.

Essentially, I create a T-junction, with each direction having 3 same-named stations with a loop back on the end (North, South, West). I then set up 2 trains going N-S, 2 going N-W, 2 going S-W, and then 2 going N-S-W and 2 going N-W-S. Essentially 2 trains going each pairing, and 2 going clockwise, 2 counter-clockwise. 10 trains, 9 stations, all utilizing the same T intersection.

The blueprints have a fair amount of unessential items (extra roboports and electrical stations), just because it is hard to carve out exactly what you need, but they should be functional, just add trains and materials for counting)

3-lane station

station.jpg (418.71 KiB) Viewed 11111 times

Crossing T-junction

crossing.jpg (397.63 KiB) Viewed 11111 times

crossing-3-station.txt

(10.69 KiB) Downloaded 281 times

Roundabout T-junction

roundabout.jpg (408.11 KiB) Viewed 11111 times

roundabout-3-station.txt

(9.79 KiB) Downloaded 298 times

I've tweaked the signal positions quite a few times, it is pretty easy to end up missing a signal and throughput on a given line goes way down. (Easy to make it so a train sitting in one station accidentally blocks a train wanting to go to a different station.) So it is possible that the measurement isn't due to roundabouts vs crossing junctions, but just because I have a signal wrong. But I have spent time trying to make them as efficient as I could. (or some detail of exactly the ordering my trains are running).

I then run it for 10 minutes (putting a storage tank into a logistic storage chest and then removing it to start and stop the counters). I then counted the how many times a train from one station made it to another station, and ended up with this mapping:

Code: Select all

Crossing Source      Roundabout Source
        N   S   W           N   S   W
    N   0   47  47      N   0   39  36
    S   47  0   47      S   40  0   49
    W   48  47  0       W   36  51  0

    Total   283                 251

I don't fully understand why some directions are skewed on the Roundabout but the T junction is very even. Possibly because the "average" length of some turns is different.
Note that I'm running 1-2-0 trains, and length would certainly have an effect, as it changes amount of time in the intersection.

I definitely did see at least 2 trains going through the intersection at the same time (2 trains turning left in left-handed traffic W=>N, and S=>W). I don't think I've seen 3 though certainly the Crossing intersection should be capable of it, I'm not sure if the signalling on the Roundabout would allow it. It should be possible, but I'm not an expert.

So ultimately, a roundabout isn't much slower than a regular crossing junction, though if you ever wanted to scale it from 2-parallel tracks to 4/6/8 parallel tracks the Crossing version probably starts to have a big advantage.

[zytukin]

Makes sense, the t-junction is a shorter distance and depending on train length and traffic volume, might not block other trains from passing where where the tracks cross over. I've used both designs in my rail layout.

But, my roundabouts are a bit different.
I run longer trains (engine + 5 cars) so I put a bunch of straight pieces on horizontal and vertical portions of the roundabout so it's more like a rounded square.

Never actually tested or compared, but my thought behind it was that the larger roundabout allows for signals between each split so the blocks would clear faster. Then a train heading east and needing to turn north wont block a train heading west for as much time, nor be blocked by it as long.

[vanatteveldt]

@zytukin: shoulnd't you use a chain signal in the middle of the roundabout there? It seems to me like it would deadlock if you get e.g. a long train coming from the E that wants to u-turn?

[zytukin]

I see what you are saying, if a long train stopped mid u-turn when that train in the picture tried to go north.
I don't have any trains in automatic mode that are longer then an engine and 5 cars, so no worries. If I need more supplies moved, I just add trains.

Although, that shouldn't happen anyway. My factory is to the west, the north area is just an Iron Mine outpost, and to the East is a stone mine and a 2nd iron mine. All the trains (16) that go to outposts only go back and forth between my factory and one outpost. So, a train wont leave the stone/iron outpost then try to turn around and go back again or go to a different outpost.

I do have 1 train that is 11 cars with 2 engines on both ends, but I only use it in manual mode to bring supplies when I am building/upgrading outposts and it has it's own track separate from the automatic trains.

[Marvin]

I used to like roundabouts, then I had a train decide to change its pathing in the middle of one so it ended up blocking itself. Now I stick to 3 way crossings.

[jameinel]

I used to like roundabouts, then I had a train decide to change its pathing in the middle of one so it ended up blocking itself. Now I stick to 3 way crossings.

So I've tried a lot of different signalling on the Roundabouts. It was very tempting to go with Rail Signal instead of Rail Chain Signal in the middle of the roundabout, but that specifically runs into the problem of a train blocking itself. Especially if you start with my original failure of a roundabout going into a "6-wide" rail system (if you just place a perfect circle with 4 corner straight pieces and then connect the curves on those) then you end up with them going 270 degrees to make the short turn.