[0.13.13-0.13.15] High GPU usage

[axazol]

100% of GPU usage and low FPS when alot of tree on screen simultaneously (max zoom and/or in forest). Meantime if i run out on free space GPU usage lowers to 30% and FPS rises back to 60.
Actual only with [video-memory-usage=all]. No issue if use 5dim_automatization_0.13.1 or Yuoki_0.3.58 separately.

screenshots

1.png (2.27 MiB) Viewed 3713 times

2.png (2.96 MiB) Viewed 3713 times

log-file:
[video-memory-usage=all]
Created atlas bitmap 16384x12971
[video-memory-usage=high]
Created atlas bitmap 16384x9801
[video-memory-usage=medium]
Created atlas bitmap 16384x4350

mods

5dim_automatization_0.13.1
5dim_core_0.13.1
5dim_mining_0.13.1
5dim_module_0.13.1
Yuoki_0.3.58

graphics

multisampling-level=0
lights-render-quality=1
fullscreen=false
system-ui-scale=false
custom-ui-scale=0.96999999999999997
preferred-screen-index=0
show-smoke=true
show-clouds=true
show-inserter-shadows=true
show-minimap=true
show-pollution-on-minimap=false
show-grid-when-paused=true
show-inserter-arrows-when-detailed-info-is-on=true
show-mining-drill-arrows-when-detailed-info-is-on=true
light-entity-info-background=false
force-opengl=false
graphics-quality=normal
v-sync=false
screenshots_queue_size=10
screenshots_threads_count=1
max-texture-size=0
video-memory-usage=all
disable-fma3=auto
show-pollution-on-large-map=true
show-turret-radius-when-blueprinting=true
show-item-labels-in-cursor=true
show-inserter-arrows-when-selected=true
show-combinator-settings-when-detailed-info-is-on=true
cache-sprite-atlas=false
trilinear-filtering=true
skip-vram-detection=false
texture-compression=false
debug_font_size=18

[Loewchen]

The frametime is (once again) lost in the flip which suggests an issue with v-sync or the driver. I lost track on the status of the v-sync debugging, but you cold try to enable it and/or switch from d3d to opengl and vice versa.
Please upload the log as well.

[Twinsen]

The frametime is (once again) lost in the flip which suggests an issue with v-sync or the driver. I lost track on the status of the v-sync debugging, but you cold try to enable it and/or switch from d3d to opengl and vice versa.
Please upload the log as well.

Actually further investigation shows that high flip times is not necessarily related to vsync. Render sends all the data to be rendered to the video card and the video card will start rendering. When we tell the video card to flip, it will sometimes have to wait for the framebuffer to actually finish drawing. So high flip times and high GPU usage means slow rendering.

Meantime if i run out on free space GPU usage lowers to 30% and FPS rises back to 60.
Actual only with [video-memory-usage=all]. No issue if use 5dim_automatization_0.13.1 or Yuoki_0.3.58 separately.

I don't exactly understand what you mean by "if i run out on free space" ?

If your video card can handle it(and yours should), you should set [video-memory-usage=all]. This means all textures will be in video memory and will render quickly, and you will have high FPS.
If you set video-memory-usage lower(for video cards that don't have enough VRAM), some textures will (sometimes) stay in system RAM, meaning it will be much slower to render them and you will have low FPS.

Can you tell me what FPS you get for each video-memory-usage setting? (make sure to test in the same savegame, in the same location, same zoom and same mods)

[axazol]

I don't exactly understand what you mean by "if i run out on free space" ?

It's mean to the area with lower count of entities around (open water or desert)

If your video card can handle it(and yours should), you should set [video-memory-usage=all]. This means all textures will be in video memory and will render quickly, and you will have high FPS.
If you set video-memory-usage lower(for video cards that don't have enough VRAM), some textures will stay in system RAM, meaning it will be much slower to render them and you will have low FPS.

Yep, it should handle it. But at [video-memory-usage=all] i still have more than 60% VRAM free. I'll test it further..

Can you tell me what FPS you get for each video-memory-usage setting? (make sure to test in the same savegame, in the same location, same zoom and same mods)

Working on it...

[axazol]

Tried to test on fresh client - all the same. In all tests max VRAM usage <= 850Mb by game

Format: old [memory setting] [char possition] ?[zoom out] [GPU usage] [GPU clock]
Gallery - http://imgur.com/a/cin73

separated links

http://imgur.com/Q6smfQt
http://imgur.com/FebBJSQ
http://imgur.com/qTMFKXw
http://imgur.com/yxoleYN
http://imgur.com/WiEeL2n
http://imgur.com/mgFqyDW
http://imgur.com/ck1C3s3
http://imgur.com/v2qNI61
http://imgur.com/nkXRP2k
http://imgur.com/RCvTMYd
http://imgur.com/gvOTr0L
http://imgur.com/sxenceM

all tree 85-1045h
all tree zoom 100-1045 (PC lagging)
all desert 38-135h
all desert zoom 56-862
high tree 14-732h
high tree zoom 58-836
high desert 40-135h
high desert zoom 60-135h 8-1054h
medium tree 31-836h
medium tree zoom 41-836
medium desert 41-135
medium desert zoom 68-135h

[Twinsen]

Thanks for the tests.
The video memory usage is ok. Based on your atlas size the video memory usage should be 16384 * 12971 * 4 = 810MB so everything seems to be loaded correctly.

But your GPU usage very odd. Your GPU should handle much more.
I have tried similar experiments on my GTX 760 (which is less powerful than yours) and to reach 100% GPU usage, I had to draw much more sprites in 4 times bigger resolution, and even so, I still had 44FPS.

screenshot

gpubound.jpg (5.39 MiB) Viewed 3636 times

Are you sure you don't have anything affecting your GPU usage or rendering? Maybe you have some settings(like texture filtering) set in your nvidia control panel?

Can you send me the list of mods you used when doing the tests? A factorio log will contain the list of mods and other useful information.

[posila]

This should be fixed in 0.13.16.
We have added option to enable mipmapping for tree sprites, which according to our measurements greatly reduces GPU load when rendering zoomed out forests.