Ok, so I deleted the port forwarding rule, then remade it in my router and it's working.

Must be time to get a new router.

Thanks for the help!

Ok, I found the client logs, and it does look like I have a network issue:

762.158 Info UDPSocket.cpp:38: Opening socket
762.159 Info ClientMultiplayerManager.cpp:603: UpdateTick(18446744073709551615) changing state from(Ready) to(Connecting)
772.168 Error ClientMultiplayerManager.cpp:85 ...

The top 2 lines are from the failing connection. The problem is that unless I try to connect using local IP the log doesnt fill out. Like it's blank until I try to log in, then those failing messages at the top populate. Are you saying those are successful ones? If so I guess I have a network ...

I am having an issue where no one can connect to my server externally.

I have a server PC separate from my gaming PC, and I had it previously set up to run a factorio server. I updated it on the server, then ran the bat file as always, but I cannot connect, and in the logs it gives a ...