[kovarex] [0.17.25] Negative emissions should record actual pollution absorbed

[Ultros]

As far as I can tell, items with negative emissions are currently only used in mods, but since the game already handles this unexpected output of negative emissions value as a pollution consumer (excellent design!), it should not be too difficult to record the actual pollution emission instead of a flat value. As-is,having any items with negative pollution emissions results in incorrect values (more pollution absorbed than produced) in the GUI.

I noticed this after playing for a while with the Air Filtering mod https://mods.factorio.com/mod/air-filtering

The mod uses a "furnace" with negative emissions to "smelt" an air filter item, but I've noticed that the amount of pollution that is showing in the pollution production system is a flat value.

https://i.imgur.com/QmOQsQM.png

I've attached a minimal test scenario using that mod to explain the issue.

[kovarex]

Thanks for the report.

It should not be too difficult to record the actual pollution emission instead of a flat value. As-is,having any items with negative pollution emissions results in incorrect values (more pollution absorbed than produced) in the GUI.

You are right, it wasn't difficult indeed

Fixed for the next version.

[AM1875]

Did this get fixed in 0.17.26? Now my pollution graph is showing pollution-emitting machines on the “consumption” side of the graph.

Vanilla 0.17.26, no mods.

screenshot

[Ultros]

Did this get fixed in 0.17.26? Now my pollution graph is showing pollution-emitting machines on the “consumption” side of the graph.

Vanilla 0.17.26, no mods.

screenshot

That doesn't make sense, these are pollution emitters, not consumers, and therefore should not fall under the category of "negative emissions" devices consuming pollution that are related to this bug report. I just downloaded 0.17.26 and set up a couple of mining drills and they are showing consumption of pollution (although they are still generating pollution), so I think this is a new bug and should be reported as such.

-edit- It's already been reported, viewtopic.php?f=7&t=69231

It appears that everything is right now, except that producers and consumers are reversed.