Confused about LTN Requester "smart filter" blueprint
Posted: Thu Jan 02, 2020 12:42 am
Hey all - I'm new to LTN and I've been trying it out for a bit now. I've been going off of the blueprints provided in the first post of the station design thread and everything mostly works great. The one thing I'm confused about is the requester blueprint (v1 and v2).
It says it's supposed to only unload items that are requested. This does not seem to happen in practice. For example I have a copper plate drop-off station that I converted to an LTN Requester station. I set the copper request to -20k. The first train came and it had a bit of stone in it that was also unloaded to my station even though I didn't set a request for it. I tried v2 as well with the extra decider combinator and that didn't work either. I've also experimented with adding other "junk" items to my train and they also got unloaded.
Am I missing something here or is this supposed to happen? From following the circuit design it seems like this is what you would expect. The train contents are being merged with the negated requested content so anything extra would simply be sent to the filter inserters un-modified (ie. in this case the residual stone) causing them to include that in their filter.
Obviously it would be easy for me to work around this by setting the copper plate filter explicitly, but then what is the whole point of the "smart filter" system?
It says it's supposed to only unload items that are requested. This does not seem to happen in practice. For example I have a copper plate drop-off station that I converted to an LTN Requester station. I set the copper request to -20k. The first train came and it had a bit of stone in it that was also unloaded to my station even though I didn't set a request for it. I tried v2 as well with the extra decider combinator and that didn't work either. I've also experimented with adding other "junk" items to my train and they also got unloaded.
Am I missing something here or is this supposed to happen? From following the circuit design it seems like this is what you would expect. The train contents are being merged with the negated requested content so anything extra would simply be sent to the filter inserters un-modified (ie. in this case the residual stone) causing them to include that in their filter.
Obviously it would be easy for me to work around this by setting the copper plate filter explicitly, but then what is the whole point of the "smart filter" system?