Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
-
- Filter Inserter
- Posts: 742
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:20 pm
- Contact:
Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Traditional single-belt lane balancers may fill the output side equally but don't draw exactly the same amount from the I put side.
Googling for "input balanced" single belt balancer designs did not yield any designs that achieve what I described. (Plus, since these could be needed on every belt that leaves the bus they'd need to be reasonably compact)..
Has anybody seen such a design? Is it even feasible without combinators?
Googling for "input balanced" single belt balancer designs did not yield any designs that achieve what I described. (Plus, since these could be needed on every belt that leaves the bus they'd need to be reasonably compact)..
Has anybody seen such a design? Is it even feasible without combinators?
- Bilka
- Factorio Staff
- Posts: 1161
- Joined: Sat Aug 13, 2016 9:20 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
The input and output balanced lane balancer on the wiki which you surely found on your search does exactly what you want:
I'm an admin over at https://wiki.factorio.com. Feel free to contact me if there's anything wrong (or right) with it.
-
- Filter Inserter
- Posts: 742
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:20 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
I use it both on exit from the smelters and on each line that branches off the bus, and it isbetter than nothing, but under some conditions the bus still gets unbalanced.Bilka wrote:The input and output balanced lane balancer on the wiki which you surely found on your search does exactly what you want:
Edit:. Never mind, the image did not load until after hitting Submit. That balancer looks different than the ones I tried. Thanks, will give it a shot.
- eradicator
- Smart Inserter
- Posts: 2604
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2016 9:03 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
- Split the input belt into seperate lanes
- Construct a full belt from each lane
- Merge the resulting lanes back into a single belt.
-
- Smart Inserter
- Posts: 2693
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 9:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
This looks to waste an underground belt. Specifically the left pair could be reduced to just one underground I think. Take the bottom left underground and the curved belt feeding it. Turn the underground 90° clockwise and put it directly after the splitter. Change it's direction to output. Add a curved belt after it to feed the second splitter.Bilka wrote:The input and output balanced lane balancer on the wiki which you surely found on your search does exactly what you want:
-
- Fast Inserter
- Posts: 103
- Joined: Tue Apr 25, 2017 2:53 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
I suspect the reason for the current design is so they can be built side by side without undergrounds interfering with each other.
-
- Smart Inserter
- Posts: 2693
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 9:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Would still work. Just don't put a mirror image of one next to it. It will connect with an underground going the other way.cbhj1 wrote:I suspect the reason for the current design is so they can be built side by side without undergrounds interfering with each other.
-
- Fast Inserter
- Posts: 150
- Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2018 5:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Why do you all make it so complicated ?
I just use a splitter and merge the two ways into a single belt....
There is no ned for the subway-belts
I just use a splitter and merge the two ways into a single belt....
There is no ned for the subway-belts

-
- Filter Inserter
- Posts: 742
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:20 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
That is the one I was using and didn't quite do the trick: split then merge on both sides of a belt.nosports wrote:Why do you all make it so complicated ?
I just use a splitter and merge the two ways into a single belt....
There is no ned for the subway-belts
That design:
- Correctly causes a full output belt.
- But under some conditions it causes one of the lanes of the input belt to be drained faster than the other. I am not sure why, but I suspect that it simply reflects the consumption.
So, I *suspect* (not know) that it is viable as an input balancer when you are drawing a half belt but not viable when you use full belts but inserters are taking items mostly from one side of the belt.
-
- Fast Inserter
- Posts: 150
- Joined: Fri Jan 19, 2018 5:44 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
I i have a given input and thous it will be symetrically placed on the single belt.
IF the drain is unsymetrically and the input can't cope with the drain there is in my opinion no way you can solve this....
if the input can cope with the drain, but a side of the belt is chocked then with the single spliter all will be sorted of the lacking side of the belt - thouse improving the throughput.
For me its easier to input just more of some to have a full output belt, because if you think of it, then it need to be full to take full advantage of a filled belt
IF you have two input belt with differnt fill just take advantage of the input/output options of the splitter, so you can choose a main feed which will be filled by the secondary feed
I suspect all will do the same, but i would not think to much of it, because either the belt needs to be full --> more input, or it is even as possible, when the output cant cope with the input symetrically, or when the drain is highly unsymetricalla, one side will chocke and the reamaing input will be sorted to the lacking side ......
IF the drain is unsymetrically and the input can't cope with the drain there is in my opinion no way you can solve this....
if the input can cope with the drain, but a side of the belt is chocked then with the single spliter all will be sorted of the lacking side of the belt - thouse improving the throughput.
For me its easier to input just more of some to have a full output belt, because if you think of it, then it need to be full to take full advantage of a filled belt
IF you have two input belt with differnt fill just take advantage of the input/output options of the splitter, so you can choose a main feed which will be filled by the secondary feed
I suspect all will do the same, but i would not think to much of it, because either the belt needs to be full --> more input, or it is even as possible, when the output cant cope with the input symetrically, or when the drain is highly unsymetricalla, one side will chocke and the reamaing input will be sorted to the lacking side ......
-
- Smart Inserter
- Posts: 2693
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 9:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
You are balancing / filling the output. But the question was about balancing the input side. Completely different issue.nosports wrote:I i have a given input and thous it will be symetrically placed on the single belt.
IF the drain is unsymetrically and the input can't cope with the drain there is in my opinion no way you can solve this....
if the input can cope with the drain, but a side of the belt is chocked then with the single spliter all will be sorted of the lacking side of the belt - thouse improving the throughput.
For me its easier to input just more of some to have a full output belt, because if you think of it, then it need to be full to take full advantage of a filled belt
IF you have two input belt with differnt fill just take advantage of the input/output options of the splitter, so you can choose a main feed which will be filled by the secondary feed
I suspect all will do the same, but i would not think to much of it, because either the belt needs to be full --> more input, or it is even as possible, when the output cant cope with the input symetrically, or when the drain is highly unsymetricalla, one side will chocke and the reamaing input will be sorted to the lacking side ......
- tzwaan
- Inserter
- Posts: 32
- Joined: Thu Jul 07, 2016 12:12 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Unfortunately, that won't work, because the splitter would then be sideloading onto the left side of the belt instead of the right side. Which means the second splitter in the balancer won't work correctly.mrvn wrote:This looks to waste an underground belt. Specifically the left pair could be reduced to just one underground I think. Take the bottom left underground and the curved belt feeding it. Turn the underground 90° clockwise and put it directly after the splitter. Change it's direction to output. Add a curved belt after it to feed the second splitter.Bilka wrote:The input and output balanced lane balancer on the wiki which you surely found on your search does exactly what you want:
- Topazy
- Manual Inserter
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Mon Feb 05, 2018 4:52 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
If you must use a lane balancer, this one is both input and output perfect
However, what you should really do is start using balanced designs that pull evenly from both sides of the belt. Lane balancers will lag the game a bit due to the game calculations involved in belts (or at least, that was the information several months ago and it doesn't look like anything has changed for them.)
However, what you should really do is start using balanced designs that pull evenly from both sides of the belt. Lane balancers will lag the game a bit due to the game calculations involved in belts (or at least, that was the information several months ago and it doesn't look like anything has changed for them.)
Last edited by Topazy on Tue Aug 28, 2018 10:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
Water table new of factorio!
-
- Smart Inserter
- Posts: 2693
- Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2016 9:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Right, you then need an extra belt so the underground belt side loads onto the belt going north and items end up on the right side of the belt again.tzwaan wrote:Unfortunately, that won't work, because the splitter would then be sideloading onto the left side of the belt instead of the right side. Which means the second splitter in the balancer won't work correctly.mrvn wrote:This looks to waste an underground belt. Specifically the left pair could be reduced to just one underground I think. Take the bottom left underground and the curved belt feeding it. Turn the underground 90° clockwise and put it directly after the splitter. Change it's direction to output. Add a curved belt after it to feed the second splitter.Bilka wrote:The input and output balanced lane balancer on the wiki which you surely found on your search does exactly what you want:
-
- Fast Inserter
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Sun Apr 30, 2017 1:39 pm
- Contact:
Re: Is it possible to input balance a single belt's lanes?
Here's one that may be what you are looking for:
Code: Select all
0eNqdlG9vgyAQh7/LvcZFsP4pX2VZFm1vC4kiAbrUGL/7sKbLotdu8hKQJ8+d3G+Epr2gsUp7kCOoU68dyNcRnPrUdTvv+cEgSFAeO2Cg625efdTOJ97W2pne+qTB1sPEQOkzXkHy6Y0Baq+8wgV3Wwzv+tI1aMMHPyC8GovOrVkMTO/C9V7PCgGZMhhAJodpYhua2NCcaZX34WzLeckXUkaRsqcFPpISFOqwD5XwO4vBWVk8LWeCIOf7yPyJZLFTUiws/rdkGUVOKckqrpOcYh2jfvCq3oIA8zTKMv0Hmcc4k53kIurpkJ3kWQyL1lrNyuPpTe7jSyvlEUFAzgUvYoqjpcrIrAsBFVL0FrvyV0oz+ELrltdSlUJU/JiWoYhvKcjx4w==
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: kosievdmerwe, Serenity and 5 guests