Page 1 of 1

[posila] [15.10] Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Mon May 15, 2017 10:25 pm
by IV 
I have the feeling that each tank of my train selects a pump upon arrival and refuses to change its' mind even if this pump is off while an other pump is on.
Some pictures. The selected pump south of the train gets enabled as soon as the train arrives (as soon as the circuit reads petrolium from the train).
Factorio 0.15.10 15_5_2017 23_53_11.png
Factorio 0.15.10 15_5_2017 23_53_11.png (2.5 MiB) Viewed 2524 times
As long as the pump in the north was not there, this was working fine. (This new pump only gets enabled if there is water in the train.)
Factorio 0.15.10 15_5_2017 23_52_24.png
Factorio 0.15.10 15_5_2017 23_52_24.png (2.62 MiB) Viewed 2524 times
The situation is asymmetric in the two pumps: if the train with water arrives the pump in the north gets enabled and starts pumping.

Re: 15.10: Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Mon May 15, 2017 10:33 pm
by Distelzombie
They are too close together. And maybe too far away from the right tank.
Place one on the far right and it will work.

Also one of the pumps is inputting into a pipe that has lubricant in them, but your train does not. maybe thats also doing something

Re: 15.10: Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Mon May 15, 2017 10:47 pm
by IV 
To clarify: This is what happens if the pump in the north is not there when the train arrives:
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_37_39.png
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_37_39.png (2.81 MiB) Viewed 2517 times
This is what happens if the pump is there
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_02_59.png
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_02_59.png (2.63 MiB) Viewed 2517 times
This is what happens if both pumps are there and the train with water arrives:
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_38_31.png
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_38_31.png (2.66 MiB) Viewed 2517 times
Distelzombie wrote:They are too close together. And maybe too far away from the right tank.
Place one on the far right and it will work.

Also one of the pumps is inputting into a pipe that has lubricant in them, but your train does not. maybe thats also doing something
I'm not quite sure what you mean by 'they are to close together'.
The pump for the lubricant is disabled (and not connected, since it was disabled when the train arrived), one can see a red light if one looks closely.

Re: 15.10: Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Mon May 15, 2017 11:20 pm
by Distelzombie
IV  wrote:To clarify: This is what happens if the pump in the north is not there when the train arrives:
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_37_39.png
This is what happens if the pump is there
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_02_59.png
This is what happens if both pumps are there and the train with water arrives:
Factorio 0.15.10 16_5_2017 0_38_31.png
Distelzombie wrote:They are too close together. And maybe too far away from the right tank.
Place one on the far right and it will work.

Also one of the pumps is inputting into a pipe that has lubricant in them, but your train does not. maybe thats also doing something
I'm not quite sure what you mean by 'they are to close together'.
The pump for the lubricant is disabled (and not connected, since it was disabled when the train arrived), one can see a red light if one looks closely.
In your first pictures it looked like the right pump above the train does not connect or cannot connect to the tank on the right. I thought you meant this one. Anyway now I know what you mean. :)

Hm. Can you put the left pump above the train one tile to the left? Maybe this helps.
Looks like a bug to me though.

Re: 15.10: Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Tue May 16, 2017 5:30 am
by IV 
Distelzombie wrote: In your first pictures it looked like the right pump above the train does not connect or cannot connect to the tank on the right. I thought you meant this one. Anyway now I know what you mean. :)

Hm. Can you put the left pump above the train one tile to the left? Maybe this helps.
Looks like a bug to me though.
I cannot put it to the left: if i do that, it will no longer connect to the other (blue) train properly.

Re: 15.10: Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Tue May 16, 2017 10:01 am
by Distelzombie
IV  wrote:
Distelzombie wrote: In your first pictures it looked like the right pump above the train does not connect or cannot connect to the tank on the right. I thought you meant this one. Anyway now I know what you mean. :)

Hm. Can you put the left pump above the train one tile to the left? Maybe this helps.
Looks like a bug to me though.
I cannot put it to the left: if i do that, it will no longer connect to the other (blue) train properly.
7
Ah, there you have it. Then put the bottom petroleum pump one to the left. It looks like it is the same position in relation to the train as the pump above the train when you put this one one to the left.

Can you post a bluerpint with both stops and the circuit stuff with pumps? You should post a bug report regardless.

Re: [posila] [15.10] Circuit enabled pump does not connect to train

Posted: Mon Jun 26, 2017 12:09 pm
by posila
Thanks for the report.
It should be fixed for 0.15.24