Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Smart setups of railway stations, intelligent routing, solutions to complex train-routing problems.
Please provide - only if it makes sense of course - a blueprint of your creation.

Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby sparr » Fri May 19, 2017 7:45 am

Screenshot 2017-05-19 00.33.40.png
Screenshot 2017-05-19 00.33.40.png (594.77 KiB) Viewed 1373 times


Inspired by https://www.reddit.com/r/factorio/comme ... ain_wagon/

Blueprint string:
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

One chest per lane unloads slower than the other two, but otherwise I think this design is good.
sparr
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 817
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2014 5:52 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby Shokubai » Fri May 19, 2017 12:47 pm

This is interesting and I like your creativity but since you can get a packed blue belt from 4 inserters per side why spend all this space if you already have blue belt?

4 red belts is 106.64 items per second
vs
2 blue belts at 80 items per second and TONS easier to manage.


Here is an example with 4 cars.
Image
Shokubai
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 468
Joined: Mon May 02, 2016 3:17 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby sparr » Fri May 19, 2017 1:06 pm

Why do we climb the mountain?

Because it is there.

Someone posted a design to reddit that made four not-packed red belts, and they suggested that they couldn't figure out how to get four packed red belts in the same space. I accepted that challenge.

Two packed blue belts is definitely a lot easier to design, and fits in smaller spaces, for minor loss of throughput.

Minor addendum: In addition to the 25% loss in belt output, your 8 inserters/chests have a 33% loss in train car unload speed over my 12.

Do you mind if I ask what the circuit conditions in your screenshot are? That looks like a perfectly balanced unloader, so I am unsure why it would need any circuits.
sparr
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 817
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2014 5:52 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby Shokubai » Fri May 19, 2017 1:10 pm

Not my image. I assume it's a load balancer (which seems odd for unloading).
Shokubai
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 468
Joined: Mon May 02, 2016 3:17 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby iceman_1212 » Fri May 19, 2017 2:40 pm

I am still coming to terms with the new longer underground belts. But here's a new way to use blues for unloading:

Image
iceman_1212
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 252
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2016 9:49 am

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby sparr » Fri May 19, 2017 2:53 pm

iceman_1212 wrote:I am still coming to terms with the new longer underground belts. But here's a new way to use blues for unloading

Are those three blue belts compressed/saturated? I didn't think twelve stack inserters could keep up.

Also, your bottom chests are going to all empty faster than your tops, I think.
sparr
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 817
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2014 5:52 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby iceman_1212 » Fri May 19, 2017 3:07 pm

sparr wrote:
iceman_1212 wrote:I am still coming to terms with the new longer underground belts. But here's a new way to use blues for unloading

Are those three blue belts compressed/saturated? I didn't think twelve stack inserters could keep up.

Also, your bottom chests are going to all empty faster than your tops, I think.


They are not compressed but I care more about throughput. I usually put a single balancer downstream and don't really care about chests unloading evenly. Was good enough for a 200k plate per min base.
iceman_1212
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 252
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2016 9:49 am

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby Dysan27 » Wed May 24, 2017 4:20 pm

You can get 3 compressed blues out using that idea you just need to do two things:
1. Set the stack size override to 8 on all 12 inserter placing on belts.
2. SLOW the inserters placing on the entrance to the UG belts by 1 tick

Image

That is a simple 48(47? forget offhand) tick clock with the insteres wired up to be enabled on 'A' = 1. This slows them just enough that the gap between sets of items are just big enough for the opposite stack inserter to fill in the gap.

Blueprint:
Code: Select all
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
Dysan27
Burner Inserter
Burner Inserter
 
Posts: 5
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2016 4:01 pm

Re: Unload four packed red belts from one cargo wagon, tileable

Postby sparr » Wed May 24, 2017 4:58 pm

Dysan27 wrote:You can get 3 compressed blues out using that idea you just need to do two things

Does this work in all four orientations?
sparr
Filter Inserter
Filter Inserter
 
Posts: 817
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2014 5:52 pm


Return to Railway Setups

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests