As always for all those bug fix.
You are an amazing team
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Wed Aug 18, 2021 2:46 pm
by disentius
Thank you:)
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Wed Aug 18, 2021 6:32 pm
by Filter62
I'm always amazed how you fix bugs I never knew existed)
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Thu Aug 19, 2021 12:01 pm
by Shadow_Man
This new cyrillic font... It has become smaller and bolder, the readability has deteriorated.
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Thu Aug 19, 2021 12:46 pm
by Klonan
Shadow_Man wrote: ↑Thu Aug 19, 2021 12:01 pm
This new cyrillic font... It has become smaller and bolder, the readability has deteriorated.
Hello,
We took quite some care in comparing before and after, making sure that the new font was as good if not better than before, considering all the different label styles, sizes, and colors.
Can you give some specific examples of where readability is negatively affected? IE specific GUIs, scales, usages, etc.
Shadow_Man wrote: ↑Thu Aug 19, 2021 12:01 pm
This new cyrillic font... It has become smaller and bolder, the readability has deteriorated.
Hello,
We took quite some care in comparing before and after, making sure that the new font was as good if not better than before, considering all the different label styles, sizes, and colors.
Can you give some specific examples of where readability is negatively affected? IE specific GUIs, scales, usages, etc.
The new font is slightly narrower and, more importantly, the lines are thinner, which makes it less readable.
Here's a comparison of version 1.1.37 and 1.1.38. (Better open/download images in new tabs with 100% scale)
OldNew
OldNew
At 125% scale (I play in this mode) a little better, but still the old font is easier for the eye to perceive.
OldNew
The bold type has become a little bolder and, together with the general narrowing, also became a little worse to be perceived.
OldNew
I believe the actual font "Titillium" that Factorio shipped with previously had no support for cyrillic whatsoever, so the "old" font that you show in your screenshots was a replacement or fallback font. I am not 100% sure where this fallback came from, but it most likely depends on your operating system, so for me (Arch Linux) it looked really bad previously (1.1.37) :
cyrillic_37.png (100.87 KiB) Viewed 20043 times
With the new, modified Titillium, the game does not pick a random font for cyrillic (1.1.38):
cyrillic_38.png (92.78 KiB) Viewed 20043 times
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Thu Aug 19, 2021 5:48 pm
by WIZ4
Shadow_Man wrote: ↑Thu Aug 19, 2021 12:01 pm
This new cyrillic font... It has become smaller and bolder, the readability has deteriorated.
I agree. The new font has become difficult to read
I believe the actual font "Titillium" that Factorio shipped with previously had no support for cyrillic whatsoever, so the "old" font that you show in your screenshots was a replacement or fallback font. I am not 100% sure where this fallback came from, but it most likely depends on your operating system, so for me (Arch Linux) it looked really bad previously (1.1.37) :
With the new, modified Titillium, the game does not pick a random font for cyrillic (1.1.38):
On my system (Windows 10 Insider Preview, without additional fonts and settings), the old and new fonts in the language list looks the same. But the old font has sharper and smoother letter lines and looks better.
OldNew
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Fri Aug 20, 2021 4:24 am
by ssilk
Maybe I didn’t understand the problem: Wouldn’t it be much easier to add Cyrillic chars to the old font? I mean, there are surely specialists out there, which have the tools to do that.
Background: typography is as complex as sound design, and for sound design you also hired someone.
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Fri Aug 20, 2021 7:17 am
by Klonan
ssilk wrote: ↑Fri Aug 20, 2021 4:24 amWouldn’t it be much easier to add Cyrillic chars to the old font?
Yes that is what the new Lilittium font is, it is Titillium extended with Cryllic characters
(Due to the OFL license, it could not re-use the Titillium name)
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Fri Aug 20, 2021 5:59 pm
by Raze1991
FactorioBot wrote: ↑Wed Aug 18, 2021 1:17 pmChanges
New Titillium style font for Cyrillic languages.
The new font looks better and is more similar to the style of the original font.
Check out my red selection to compare old, new and the original one.
Fonts compare
Zoom in pictures to see more details.
Old font
1.1.37_Rus.png (59.43 KiB) Viewed 18986 times
~
New font
1.1.38_Rus.png (56.65 KiB) Viewed 18986 times
~
Original font
1.1.38_Eng.png (53.64 KiB) Viewed 18986 times
Pay special attention to the text in front of the tooltip icons.
Thanks a lot for this change!
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Sat Aug 21, 2021 2:48 pm
by Shadow_Man
What about adding 2 (or more) fonts to the interface options?
Or ability to choose font from OS fonts?
And size of font?
Upd:
There are several fonts included in Core/Fonts folder, and font selection order in Locale/XX/info.json file.
Maybe add option to adjust that font styles order?
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Sat Aug 21, 2021 3:54 pm
by velesarcanum
Hello. I would be glad if they returned the old style for the Russian (Cyrillic) text. With the new update (38), the font has become unreadable. Eyes get tired very quickly. Which is not good news, especially on a laptop. Yesterday, after installing the update, after 3-5 minutes my eyes got tired. Which has never happened before in 2 years.
Or at least add an option so that you can choose the desired font yourself.
I believe the actual font "Titillium" that Factorio shipped with previously had no support for cyrillic whatsoever, so the "old" font that you show in your screenshots was a replacement or fallback font. I am not 100% sure where this fallback came from, but it most likely depends on your operating system, so for me (Arch Linux) it looked really bad previously (1.1.37) :
With the new, modified Titillium, the game does not pick a random font for cyrillic (1.1.38):
On my system (Windows 10 Insider Preview, without additional fonts and settings), the old and new fonts in the language list looks the same. But the old font has sharper and smoother letter lines and looks better.
OldNew
Agree. The old font looks better. And his eyes do not hurt.
Do you know how to get through to developers so that they at least turn on the ability to choose the desired font?
I believe the actual font "Titillium" that Factorio shipped with previously had no support for cyrillic whatsoever, so the "old" font that you show in your screenshots was a replacement or fallback font. I am not 100% sure where this fallback came from, but it most likely depends on your operating system, so for me (Arch Linux) it looked really bad previously (1.1.37) :
With the new, modified Titillium, the game does not pick a random font for cyrillic (1.1.38):
On my system (Windows 10 Insider Preview, without additional fonts and settings), the old and new fonts in the language list looks the same. But the old font has sharper and smoother letter lines and looks better.
OldNew
What confuses me about this observation in particular is that Swedish "Svenska" changes from "old" to "new", as do the numbers.
But neither Latin part of the font, nor the numbers have been touched (from what I understand) between the two versions in question.
It is almost as if the font is rendered with different settings, especially "weak" vs "strong" hinting, or as if there is unintended font replacement happening in the background. There is definitely some OS-specific thing going on here.
This change does not happen on my Linux system, the look of "Svenska" and of the numbers is the same in the screenshots that I provided in this post:
valneq wrote: ↑Fri Aug 27, 2021 8:12 am
It is almost as if the font is rendered with different settings, especially "weak" vs "strong" hinting, or as if there is unintended font replacement happening in the background. There is definitely some OS-specific thing going on here.
This change does not happen on my Linux system, the look of "Svenska" and of the numbers is the same in the screenshots that I provided in this post:
In Factorio 1.1.37 main font was Lato, in the last update 1.1.38 new font is Lilittium. They differ in the style of letters, both Latin and Cyrillic, and numbers. The Lato font is more "rounded", but in your screenshots the old font is clearly not Lato. Apparently, for some reason, it is not used, and the system loaded the next font from the list or used a similar font (this happens when the font is not available).
Here some comparison of fonts with Russian test phrase:
(I am using Tahoma now, much more easy to read)
fonts 100.png (77.4 KiB) Viewed 15342 times
Re: Version 1.1.38
Posted: Fri Aug 27, 2021 2:52 pm
by ikm
This font also has kerning problems. For example, in main menu "Звук" looks more like "З вук".