Page 1 of 2

Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2016 3:51 pm
by grouchysmurf
Right, so first I must say the early game is what I am enjoying best: making most with very limited resources is what I'm keen on (that's sad that coal age doesn't - and can't - last for long; most of facilities require electricity which renders burner drills and my favourite burner inserters everything but useful). That is why I tinker mostly with low level designs.

Anyway, early game is also a research rush - you want to establish your defences as soon as possible, start the trains and crack oil so setting up red / green science production is of crucial importance.

With no automation, you would provide resources by yourself i.e. put them in chests, as few as possible, preferably. The following should let you through first red researches:

Image

Should you discover automation T2, you may establish green science factory; there are dozens of approaches - mine uses hardly any belts, hand-crafting of which takes time and in general is against spirit of factorio where you strive to AUTOMATE all the things. There are only two input chests: one for iron plates, the other for copper ones. You may want to feed into first one as many of them as possible, as the factory eats them up in a fast pace:

Image

Later on you would simply feed in two belts, one with copper, other one with iron to automate the production:

Image

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2016 4:19 pm
by brunzenstein
I fully agree with you - find get clever solutions within the first ⅓ within the game is the most fun.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Wed Sep 07, 2016 8:36 pm
by AlyxDeLunar
I really like your design for the green science. It's compact but still simple and tidy. I do love tidy builds :D

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Sep 08, 2016 3:43 pm
by grouchysmurf
Thanks.

Just don't you forget to limit storage of the chests to just one slot or you may end up with hundreds of iron gears.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2016 11:04 am
by mennoo1996
Did you ever try the marathon mod? It lengthens the early game/burner stage a lot

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2016 4:46 pm
by vanatteveldt
Nice design. I always automate circuits before green science, but I guess there is really no need to.

If you move the cable and circuit assemblers one down, it is a bit more compact and looks better (imho) because the top assemblers are aligned.

Edit: for reference, this is the green/red I am currently using. Has a single copper+iron belt as input and a green/red belt as output:
science

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2016 7:29 pm
by grouchysmurf
You're right, it looks a bit more compact:

Image

Personally I strive to feed in only raw resources i.e. I would always make green circuits on site.

Yours is very clean and "airy", from the lack of better word. I like how you managed to align all assemblers in one line - looks neat!

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2016 9:11 pm
by zebediah49
If you're willing to give up the intermediate chests, you can drop the long-inserter requirement as well

Image

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 3:23 pm
by grouchysmurf
@zebediah49: hey, that looks cool! Thanks, that's even simpler and neater. However, I am not that sure about giving up on chests -- they are a buffers of some kinds and should there be a shortage of anything, science would keep on going. That's not something, though, that would made me not using your design so thanks for sharing :-)

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2016 4:52 am
by Guu
my decision, where each assembly has a dual task

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2016 10:08 pm
by Quax
grouchysmurf wrote:You're right, it looks a bit more compact:

Image

Personally I strive to feed in only raw resources i.e. I would always make green circuits on site.

Yours is very clean and "airy", from the lack of better word. I like how you managed to align all assemblers in one line - looks neat!
How do you get an even production in this setup? I have one side running idle allways as the gear factory cannot satisfy both the needs of the belt and the inserter factory?

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2016 6:10 am
by Mehve
You can't run both the belt and the inserter assembler at full speed from a single gear assembler. What should happen over time is one of the two assemblers backs up, since they're being made faster than the green pack assemblers are using them, at which point the other gets their full share of the gears produced, and things level out. But if you have too many assemblers, that will never happen. Assuming similar tier assemblers, I imagine you'd be good for roughly 5 or 6 green pack assemblers per gear assembler.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2016 11:31 am
by Quax
Mehve wrote:You can't run both the belt and the inserter assembler at full speed from a single gear assembler. What should happen over time is one of the two assemblers backs up, since they're being made faster than the green pack assemblers are using them, at which point the other gets their full share of the gears produced, and things level out. But if you have too many assemblers, that will never happen. Assuming similar tier assemblers, I imagine you'd be good for roughly 5 or 6 green pack assemblers per gear assembler.
You're right, I wittnessed that after some minutes (half an hour?) of gameplay both gear boxes are filled up (I set a maximum of 100 gears for each), thus making the inserter/belt production more or less Independent from each other.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2016 2:12 pm
by mrvn
Quax wrote:
Mehve wrote:You can't run both the belt and the inserter assembler at full speed from a single gear assembler. What should happen over time is one of the two assemblers backs up, since they're being made faster than the green pack assemblers are using them, at which point the other gets their full share of the gears produced, and things level out. But if you have too many assemblers, that will never happen. Assuming similar tier assemblers, I imagine you'd be good for roughly 5 or 6 green pack assemblers per gear assembler.
You're right, I wittnessed that after some minutes (half an hour?) of gameplay both gear boxes are filled up (I set a maximum of 100 gears for each), thus making the inserter/belt production more or less Independent from each other.
That's why I would always make this without chests. The buffer means one side will get way to many on some things before it blocks and the other side gets to run. Early on this is the worst. The gear factory will eat up all the iron plates and then the circuit boards can't be produced due to lack of them and so on.

There is also a trick you can do in some cases: Feed the assembler with one or more fast inserters and remove the product with two slow inserters. If you can produce items faster than one slow inserter can handle then they will alternate between the two slow inserters giving you an even split. Only works if you can sustain the production speed. If you don't input enough source materials then usually one side still gets all output till it blocks.

The setup above really could use a few fast inserters too. By the time you need green science you should be able to afford a few.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 1:20 pm
by renius
Very early rg science that can be scaleable

Image

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 3:49 pm
by huliosh
more compact and balanced
Image

edit:
Not a problem, it's even more balanced.
Image

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Thu Jan 19, 2017 4:26 pm
by Xeanoa
huliosh wrote:more compact and balanced
But yellow assemblers are not early game. You'll need two plants for copper wire and two for gear wheels.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Fri Jan 20, 2017 11:36 am
by mrvn
Nice

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2017 9:58 pm
by Nich
huliosh wrote: Image

I love this design it is the same basic thing I came up with after 3 hours of farting around :/ Except you version has every thing tightened up better. I also fed mine with a 1/2 copper 1/2 iron input.

You can also pull off extra belts and inserters as they can support up to 12 green assemblers (if you upgrade belts to blue). but I like the 5/6/12 science ratio.

Re: Very early r/g science factories

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2017 2:10 pm
by vanatteveldt
huliosh wrote:more compact and balanced
Why the long-handed inserters where normal inserters would work as well? Also, for 6 science assemblers, do you actually need the extra gear+cable?