Factorio Forums

https://drive.google.com/file/d/15oULKf ... sp=sharing

What did you do?

Flying towards the shattered planet, my space platform was hit by a huge asteroid, destroying it.

What happened?
Luckily I had an autosave a few seconds before the asteroid hits. (linked above)
In this savefile you can see there is a railgun turret prioritising huge oxide asteroids right in the path of the huge oxide asteroid. The railgun cycles through states 3,4&5 (I understand these relate to the turret firing) but the turret doesn't fire. It has ammo and power.

What did you expect to happen instead? It might be obvious to you, but do it anyway!

I expected the railguns to shoot the huge oxide asteroid.

Does it happen always, once, or sometimes?

This happens repeatedly from this savefile but in general its a very occasional occurrence.

Happens randomly to me too and the sole reason why I considered adding a mod to increase railgun animation speed by 2x

Hi, stepping through with the editor I also can't find any issue.

Deconstructing the railgun and rebuilding it, which resets the target sometimes destroys the aforementioned asteroid but not always.
I would guess this is just a rare case of "not enough railgun shooting speed" where there can be rare cases of asteroids slipping through the firing arcs of the railguns.

Also (maybe somewhat) related 121657

Theragus wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 12:48 pm Hi, stepping through with the editor I also can't find any issue.

Deconstructing the railgun and rebuilding it, which resets the target sometimes destroys the aforementioned asteroid but not always.
I would guess this is just a rare case of "not enough railgun shooting speed" where there can be rare cases of asteroids slipping through the firing arcs of the railguns.

It is actually not that rare and happens to me too.
If you let the linked save run over night you will lose all or most of the Promethium haulers.
But maybe this is just fixed with more shooting speed.

Another one (Maybe somewhat) related 116987

Fredibob wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 5:13 pm

Theragus wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 12:48 pm Hi, stepping through with the editor I also can't find any issue.

Deconstructing the railgun and rebuilding it, which resets the target sometimes destroys the aforementioned asteroid but not always.
I would guess this is just a rare case of "not enough railgun shooting speed" where there can be rare cases of asteroids slipping through the firing arcs of the railguns.

It is actually not that rare and happens to me too.
If you let the linked save run over night you will lose all or most of the Promethium haulers.
But maybe this is just fixed with more shooting speed.

Unfortunately from what I've seen in the chats and forums the last few days, Railguns are currently not 100% reliable when it actually comes to fulfilling their exact role which is especially egregious since they are the only way to handle huge asteroids.
as in my linked reports, railguns don't benefit from shooting speed after a certain point because their animation is their limiting factor.

Relating to the fact you said that you will lose most of the Prom haulers in the provided save if you let them run long enough, unfortunately, the only solution I think there is currently is adding more Railguns to counter their unreliable targeting.

Theragus wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 12:48 pm Hi, stepping through with the editor I also can't find any issue.

If you look at the debug output (f4 option) for the railgun prioritising huge oxide asteroids in a direct line of fire of the asteroid then you will see it starts in state 3 progress 0.54. State 3 is preparing to fire. Then it progresses through state 4 (firing) and state 5 (post firing) but never actually fires.

The railgun has shooting speed is 0.86 shots / s that means it should be able to shoot every ~70 ticks, more shooting speed research doesn't increase the shooting speed stat. (I think this was done because the issue with the animation speed)

The animation (states 3 -> 5) seems to be 71 ticks long so that fits with the shooting speed.

Stevetrov wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 7:36 pm

Theragus wrote: ↑Sun Dec 01, 2024 12:48 pm Hi, stepping through with the editor I also can't find any issue.

If you look at the debug output (f4 option) for the railgun prioritising huge oxide asteroids in a direct line of fire of the asteroid then you will see it starts in state 3 progress 0.54. State 3 is preparing to fire. Then it progresses through state 4 (firing) and state 5 (post firing) but never actually fires.

I also noticed this issue but I assumed this was due to the asteroid getting too close before the railgun could actually fire.
I saw another bug report earlier which did have a similar issue with rocket turrets and wild biter spawners because spawners actually have a separate bounding box than the graphic one which was preventing rocket turrets from firing capute rockets despite the turret visuals showing it was "In range".

I saw another bug report earlier which did have a similar issue with rocket turrets and wild biter spawners because spawners actually have a separate bounding box than the graphic one which was preventing rocket turrets from firing capute rockets despite the turret visuals showing it was "In range".

Lol that was another of my bug reports.

It could be something like that but rather than minimum range it might be that its not in the firing arc.

Thanks for the report. I looked into this and found that while yes the railgun is limited by the animation speed (as other reports have mentioned), it's not as simple as just that. The underlying issue was: a railgun would lock onto an asteroid and begin it's 'charge up' animation to fire (this is where most of the delay is). If between the charge up starting and being finished the asteroid is destroyed or moves out of range, it wouldn't attempt to find a new target to shoot until the in-progress charge up animation finished. At that point, it would search, find a new target, and start the animation over again. This meant it could keep re-targeting asteroids that got killed by other rail-guns and never actually fire on anything even if it was fully ready to do so.

I've fixed it for the next release so if while charging up the railguns target is invalidated it will simply acquire a new one and continue the charge-up cycle until it eventually shoots at one of them. In your save file, this resulted in so many large, medium, and small asteroids that it overwhelmed the platform and it exploded from all the impacts.

Rseding91 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2024 9:50 pm In your save file, this resulted in so many large, medium, and small asteroids that it overwhelmed the platform and it exploded from all the impacts.

I am not surprised that ship was rather tuned to the environment.

Since I switched to 2.0.24, my ship doesn´t randomly "miss" huge asteroid anymore! I'm even able to go full speed at 450kms vs the 120kms I had to limit before (and still miss some).

So at least for me, 2.0.24 fixed this, thanks Wube!